diff --git a/.planning/ROADMAP.md b/.planning/ROADMAP.md index 2eb13a945..5557d4117 100644 --- a/.planning/ROADMAP.md +++ b/.planning/ROADMAP.md @@ -23,7 +23,7 @@ None - this is internal GSD development following existing command/workflow/temp - [x] **Phase 13: Dedicated Debug Agent** - Create gsd-debugger agent, refactor /gsd:debug to thin orchestrator - [x] **Phase 14: Dedicated Researcher Agent** - Create gsd-researcher agent for structured research with baked-in methodology - [x] **Phase 15: Dedicated Planner Agent** - Create gsd-planner agent, refactor /gsd:plan-phase to thin orchestrator -- [ ] **Phase 16: Plan Verification Loop** - Add planner → checker → revise loop before execution +- [x] **Phase 16: Plan Verification Loop** - Add planner → checker → revise loop before execution - [x] **Phase 99: Test Parallel (THROWAWAY)** - Create 3 silly independent files to test parallel execution ## Phase Details @@ -293,9 +293,9 @@ Created gsd-planner agent with complete planning methodology: discovery levels, **Plans:** 3 plans Plans: -- [ ] 16-01: Create gsd-plan-checker agent - Goal-backward plan verification (~400-600 lines) -- [ ] 16-02: Update plan-phase.md orchestrator - Planner → checker → revise loop -- [ ] 16-03: Update gsd-planner.md - Add revision mode for handling checker feedback +- [x] 16-01: Create gsd-plan-checker agent - Goal-backward plan verification (744 lines) +- [x] 16-02: Update plan-phase.md orchestrator - Planner → checker → revise loop (310 lines) +- [x] 16-03: Update gsd-planner.md - Add revision mode for handling checker feedback (1,284 lines total) **Wave structure:** - Wave 1: 16-01 (foundation) @@ -348,4 +348,4 @@ Phases execute in numeric order: 1 → 2 → 3 → 4 → 5 → 6 | 13. Dedicated Debug Agent | 3/3 | Complete | 2026-01-15 | | 14. Dedicated Researcher Agent | 3/3 | Complete | 2026-01-15 | | 15. Dedicated Planner Agent | 3/3 | Complete | 2026-01-16 | -| 16. Plan Verification Loop | 0/3 | Planned | - | +| 16. Plan Verification Loop | 3/3 | Complete | 2026-01-16 | diff --git a/.planning/STATE.md b/.planning/STATE.md index 13fc5eb76..a8a8bfffe 100644 --- a/.planning/STATE.md +++ b/.planning/STATE.md @@ -128,8 +128,8 @@ None yet. ## Project Alignment Last checked: 2026-01-16 -Status: ON TRACK -Assessment: Phase 16 added. Plan verification loop — planner → checker → revise orchestration before execution. +Status: COMPLETE +Assessment: Phase 16 complete. Plan verification loop — gsd-plan-checker (744 lines), plan-phase orchestrator loop (310 lines), gsd-planner revision mode (1,284 lines). Drift notes: None ## Session Continuity diff --git a/.planning/phases/16-plan-verification-loop/16-VERIFICATION.md b/.planning/phases/16-plan-verification-loop/16-VERIFICATION.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c6abb75ce --- /dev/null +++ b/.planning/phases/16-plan-verification-loop/16-VERIFICATION.md @@ -0,0 +1,96 @@ +--- +phase: 16-plan-verification-loop +verified: 2026-01-16T15:30:00Z +status: passed +score: 12/12 must-haves verified +--- + +# Phase 16: Plan Verification Loop Verification Report + +**Phase Goal:** Add plan verification between planning and execution — planner -> checker -> revise loop +**Verified:** 2026-01-16 +**Status:** passed +**Re-verification:** No — initial verification + +## Goal Achievement + +### Observable Truths + +| # | Truth | Status | Evidence | +|---|-------|--------|----------| +| 1 | Plan checker can load PLAN.md files and parse frontmatter | VERIFIED | `gsd-plan-checker.md` lines 250-302: Step 2-3 document loading PLAN.md files and parsing frontmatter | +| 2 | Plan checker can verify plans against phase goal from ROADMAP.md | VERIFIED | `gsd-plan-checker.md` lines 253-261: Extracts phase goal from ROADMAP.md | +| 3 | Plan checker returns structured issues or passed status | VERIFIED | `gsd-plan-checker.md` lines 630-706: `## VERIFICATION PASSED` and `## ISSUES FOUND` structured returns | +| 4 | Checker output is consumable by orchestrator and planner | VERIFIED | `gsd-plan-checker.md` lines 569-627: YAML issue structure with plan, dimension, severity, fix_hint | +| 5 | Orchestrator spawns gsd-planner then gsd-plan-checker | VERIFIED | `plan-phase.md` steps 6 and 8: Task() spawns for gsd-planner then gsd-plan-checker | +| 6 | User sees status between agent spawns | VERIFIED | `plan-phase.md` lines 94, 174, 225, 263: Display statements between each spawn | +| 7 | If issues found, planner is re-spawned with feedback | VERIFIED | `plan-phase.md` lines 219-259: Step 10 spawns planner with revision_context containing issues | +| 8 | Loop terminates after max 3 iterations or passed | VERIFIED | `plan-phase.md` lines 221, 223, 261-271: iteration_count tracking, max 3 check, user options | +| 9 | Planner can accept checker feedback in revision mode | VERIFIED | `gsd-planner.md` line 842-945: `` section accepts `` with issues | +| 10 | Planner reads existing PLAN.md files when revising | VERIFIED | `gsd-planner.md` lines 850-861: Step 1 loads existing PLAN.md files | +| 11 | Planner makes targeted updates, not full replan | VERIFIED | `gsd-planner.md` lines 894-906: DO/DO NOT guidance - "Surgeon, not architect" mindset | +| 12 | Planner returns what changed for user visibility | VERIFIED | `gsd-planner.md` lines 917-943: Step 6 returns `## REVISION COMPLETE` with changes table | + +**Score:** 12/12 truths verified + +### Required Artifacts + +| Artifact | Expected | Status | Details | +|----------|----------|--------|---------| +| `agents/gsd-plan-checker.md` | Plan verification agent (400-600 lines) | VERIFIED | 744 lines, 9 sections (exceeds 7 required), complete methodology | +| `commands/gsd/plan-phase.md` | Orchestrator with verification loop (200+ lines) | VERIFIED | 310 lines, 11 process steps, planner -> checker -> revise loop | +| `agents/gsd-planner.md` | Planner with revision mode (1100+ lines) | VERIFIED | 1284 lines, revision_mode section added (~105 lines) | + +### Key Link Verification + +| From | To | Via | Status | Details | +|------|-----|-----|--------|---------| +| plan-phase.md | gsd-planner | Task() spawn | WIRED | Lines 147-153, 250-256 | +| plan-phase.md | gsd-plan-checker | Task() spawn | WIRED | Lines 199-205 | +| checker output | planner revision | issues in revision_context | WIRED | Lines 229-247 pass issues to planner | +| gsd-plan-checker | PLAN.md files | Read in verification_process | WIRED | Lines 250-302 load PLAN.md | +| gsd-plan-checker | ROADMAP.md | Phase goal extraction | WIRED | Lines 253-254 extract goal | +| gsd-planner revision | existing PLANs | Read tool | WIRED | Lines 850-856 load existing plans | +| gsd-planner revision | checker issues | revision_context | WIRED | Lines 863-879 parse issue format | + +### Requirements Coverage + +| Requirement | Status | Evidence | +|-------------|--------|----------| +| gsd-plan-checker agent created | SATISFIED | `agents/gsd-plan-checker.md` (744 lines) | +| plan-phase.md orchestrates planner -> checker loop | SATISFIED | Steps 6-10 in process section | +| User sees status between agent spawns | SATISFIED | Display statements at each step | +| Checker verifies plans against phase goal | SATISFIED | 6 verification dimensions | +| Planner can revise based on feedback | SATISFIED | `` section | +| Loop terminates (max 3 iterations or passed) | SATISFIED | iteration_count tracking | +| Plans verified before execution available | SATISFIED | Complete flow verified | + +### Anti-Patterns Found + +| File | Line | Pattern | Severity | Impact | +|------|------|---------|----------|--------| +| - | - | - | - | No anti-patterns found | + +No TODO, FIXME, placeholder, or stub patterns detected in any of the three artifacts. + +### Human Verification Required + +None required. All phase deliverables are documentable artifacts (markdown files) that can be fully verified programmatically. + +### Gaps Summary + +No gaps found. All 12 must-have truths verified. All 3 artifacts exist, are substantive (exceed minimum line counts), and are properly wired together. The verification loop is complete: + +1. `plan-phase.md` spawns `gsd-planner` +2. Planner creates PLAN.md files +3. `plan-phase.md` spawns `gsd-plan-checker` +4. Checker verifies plans, returns passed or issues +5. If issues, `plan-phase.md` spawns planner with revision_context +6. Planner makes targeted updates (revision_mode) +7. Loop repeats up to 3 iterations or until passed +8. User sees status throughout + +--- + +_Verified: 2026-01-16_ +_Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier)_