a9a7a328e6e9ec5bc494b9d8862fbe5cd79c185d
7 Commits
| Author | SHA1 | Message | Date | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Jakub Zych
|
a9a7a328e6 |
refactor: hard-fork GSD -> MSD (Make Software Done)
Mechanical rename produced by scripts/msd-rename.cjs: gsd/Gsd/GSD -> msd/Msd/MSD across contents and paths, upstream package/repo coordinates -> @golem15/msd-core and golem15com/msd-core. Deep links into upstream history, sibling upstream packages, the GSD-2 import feature, CHANGELOG.md and .changeset/ are kept as-is. Hand edits on top: MSD block-letter banner and logos, LICENSE copyright line, package/plugin identity, regenerated lockfile, install-tree fixtures, derived registries and benchmark baseline; migration checksum baseline re-locked (MSD keeps its own install state, so no install had applied the old sums); sort-order and regex-escaped expectations in tests adjusted. |
||
|
Dennis Alexis Valin Dittrich
|
ad1477d659 |
enhance(#4154): validate configured entrypoints before reporting install success (#4249)
* test(260903-m7p): expose configured-entrypoint validation gap * enhance(260903-m7p): validate configured entrypoints before success * test(260903-m7p): require pre-success entrypoint validation * enhance(260903-m7p): gate install success on entrypoints * test(260903-m7p): cover configured entrypoints across runtimes * enhance(260903-m7p): cover emitted runtime entrypoints * fix(260903-m7p): sandbox HOME in finishInstall test and fix changeset pr number - finishInstall(...'cline'...) calls writeNonClaudeDefaults(runtime) in-process before the new configured-entrypoint assertion throws. Without a HOME + config-location-env sandbox that write resolved through the ambient environment and landed in the developer's live ~/.gsd (confirmed absent on origin/next baseline, present only on this branch — full-suite HERMETICITY WARNING). Sandbox HOME/USERPROFILE and scrub config-location env for the duration of the test, matching the existing in-process finishInstall/ install() pattern in tests/install.test.cjs (#2665). - .changeset/quick-wasps-sing.md: pr: 0 is a never-backfilled placeholder (CONTRIBUTING.md) that fails changeset-lint's invalid_pr check; set to the fork PR number until the upstream PR number is known. * fix(260903-m7p): repair cross-platform and pre-existing shape fallout - tests/configured-entrypoint-validation.test.cjs: the win32 branch of ensureCodexHooksJsonSessionStart writes a .cmd shim under <codexRoot>/hooks/; create that dir in the test (the real installer only calls this once hooks/gsd-check-update.js already exists) and assert the platform-common entrypoint shape instead of a fixed non-Windows array, since win32 legitimately emits two entries (cmd shim + script). - tests/install.test.cjs: finishInstall's shared settings-json return now carries configuredEntrypoints/rollbackInstallerMigrations for every runtime on that path (trae included, not just Claude/Cursor/Windsurf); update the trae install() exact-shape assertion to match. * fix(260903-m7p): keep .sh interpreter tracking consistent with unresolved bash configuredEntrypointsForHook's shell branch dropped interpreterCandidates entirely when resolveBashExecutable returned null, unlike the sibling portableHooks runner entry a few lines below (which correctly falls back to the literal 'bash' token). Found via agy adversarial review; verified unreachable through the current call graph (buildHookCommand's own resolveBashRunner==null gate already short-circuits before recordConfiguredHookCommand runs), so this is a defensive consistency fix, not a live-bug patch — kept for the next caller that does not share that gate. * chore(260903-m7p): backfill changeset pr number to the opened upstream PR .changeset/quick-wasps-sing.md carried the fork PR number (16) as a placeholder until the upstream PR existed; open-gsd/gsd-core#4249 is now open, so record its real number per CONTRIBUTING.md's changeset pr-field convention. * fix(#4154): track already-registered hooks for entrypoint validation on update applySettingsJsonHooks registers each guard hook only if absent, so a hook already present from a prior install keeps its stale on-disk command. The new entrypoint tracker always records the freshly-computed command for it, which never matches what is actually persisted, so the exact-string filter in finishInstall silently dropped it from validation — the Blocker case this feature exists to catch (an already-installed entrypoint going stale between installs) was exactly the case it never validated. Match on the managed script's basename instead, which the persisted command carries either way, so an already-registered hook stays in the validated set. Regression test forces this path by mutating a freshly-installed hook's persisted command before a second install. * fix(#4154): distinguish an unreadable script from a missing one validateConfiguredEntrypoints folded an EACCES statSync failure into the same 'missing' reason as ENOENT, misreporting a real permission problem as an absent file. Check the error code and report 'unreadable' instead. * docs(#4154): document entrypoint validation's rollback and PATH scope CONTEXT.md's Runtime Hooks Surface Module / Installer Module entries had no mention of ConfiguredEntrypoint/validateConfiguredEntrypoints, despite bin/install.js x CONTEXT.md being this repo's strongest co-change pairing. The update-gsd.md how-to overstated what a validation failure undoes: for Codex/Cursor/Windsurf/Kimi, their own writer already persisted hooks.json/ config.toml inside install() before the aggregate validation call runs, so there is no rollback path for that write regardless of "where available" phrasing. Also note that interpreter resolution checks the installer's own PATH, not necessarily the PATH a hook fires under later (#2979 launchers). * chore(#4154): point changeset pr field at the fork PR while CI runs there Mirrors the branch's own prior backfill commit: pr: matches whichever PR number changeset-lint is currently validating against (fork PR #16 during the fork-first CI/review loop), flipped back to the upstream PR number right before the final push to open-gsd/gsd-core. * fix(#4249): address adversarial-review findings in entrypoint validation An internal adversarial review (agy/gemini-3.8-flash-high) of the whole PR found several real gaps beyond the human reviewer's Blocker, verified against source before fixing: - Codex's install() result bound rollbackInstallerMigrations to the narrow installer-migrations-only rollback instead of restoreCodexSnapshot (#3245), the full pre-install snapshot/restore Codex already owns for exactly this case — a validation failure discovered outside install() reverted nothing of the config.toml/hooks.json that call had already written. - The register-only-if-absent basename match from the prior fix used a bare substring, which an unrelated user command mentioning the same filename could false-positive into GSD's validated set — anchored on the `/hooks/<basename>` path segment instead. - nodeCandidates checked raw process.execPath (always true — we're running in that process) instead of normalizeNodePath's stable version-manager alias, the same one buildNodeRunnerChainToken bakes as its first choice — a false green regardless of whether that alias itself still resolves. - An entry with no interpreterCandidates (Cline's PreToolUse hook, or a Windows-Claude .sh hook invoked without a bash runner) runs via its own shebang; validateConfiguredEntrypoints checked only file-type, never the execute bit. Cline's writer also never reported an entrypoint at all. - Duplicate (configPath, scriptPath) entries (e.g. Kimi's context-monitor hook registered across several events) were validated once per duplicate. Each fix is covered by a new or extended test; the Codex one required inlining runCodexInstall's env sandboxing so the rollback closure — which re-resolves the $HOME-relative skills root live — runs before the sandbox is torn down, matching how installAllRuntimes' real aggregate gate calls it. * docs(#4249): document the round-2 entrypoint-validation fixes Runtime Hooks Surface Module and Installer Module entries now name ConfiguredEntrypoint's not-executable reason, the normalizeNodePath alignment, Cline's tracked hook, and which install() result the finishInstall/installAllRuntimes rollback path actually reverts per runtime (Codex's full snapshot vs. the others' narrow migrations-only rollback). * chore(#4249): point changeset pr field at the upstream PR now that fork CI is green * fix(#4249): address agy adversarial-review findings - validateConfiguredEntrypoints: statSync alone never detects a chmod-000 script (it only needs parent-dir search permission), so an interpreter-invoked entry with an unreadable script passed validation. Add an explicit R_OK check for the interpreterCandidates branch only — the candidate-less/shebang branch already has its own X_OK gate. - docs/how-to/update-gsd.md: the blanket "does not revert" claim was false for Codex, which reverts config.toml/hooks.json via its full pre-install snapshot; qualify it per runtime. - tests/codex-config.test.cjs: the #4249 rollback regression test asserted skills/ and VERSION were reverted but never asserted config.toml/hooks.json were too, despite the test's own stated intent. - CONTEXT.md: qualify which interpreterCandidates entries get normalizeNodePath'd (Node hooks only, not .sh/bash) and note Codex's Windows .cmd shim as a third candidate-less case that relies on extension dispatch, not a shebang. * fix(#4249): validate Cline's PATH-dependent interpreter, not just its execute bit Cline's hook is a hybrid: it self-executes via '#!/usr/bin/env node', so it needs the execute bit (like any shebang-invoked entry), but its interpreter is looked up on PATH by 'env' at hook-fire time (unlike every other GSD JS hook, which bakes an absolute node path specifically to avoid that dependency). The candidate-less/interpreterCandidates fork treated these as mutually exclusive, so Cline's entry silently skipped interpreter resolution entirely — a completely missing 'node' on PATH would still validate successfully. Add an orthogonal selfExecutable flag so both checks run for entries that need them. (CodeRabbit finding on the fork rehearsal PR.) * fix(#4249): address second-round adversarial review findings (opus + agy) - validateConfiguredEntrypoints: R_OK now runs for every scriptOk entry, not just interpreterCandidates ones — a self-executable shebang script is still opened and read by its kernel-invoked interpreter, so X_OK alone never proved it was readable. - selfExecutable is now the sole, explicit source of truth for the execute-bit check (every producer that needs it sets the flag) instead of being partly inferred from an absent interpreterCandidates, which Cline's hybrid entry also carries. - The execute-bit check now skips explicitly on win32 (matching resolveExecutableBinary's own carve-out) instead of relying on Node's accessSync(X_OK)-as-F_OK no-op, which only protects a real Windows machine and not a test that simulates win32 on a POSIX runner. - bin/install.js: fixed a stale comment claiming no runtime's install()-time writes have a rollback path — Codex's does (restoreCodexSnapshot) — and added the omitted Cline to both that comment and CONTEXT.md's equivalent lists. - CONTEXT.md: fixed the Cline description left stale by the previous commit's selfExecutable addition, and rewrote the validation-mechanism paragraph for clarity (writing-for-agents pass). - docs/how-to/update-gsd.md: split an overloaded 4-clause sentence. - Removed a fault-injection integration test that could not reliably exercise the real installAllRuntimes -> finalize -> rollback wiring without fighting the installer's own pre-registration existence guards; the constituent pieces remain covered individually. * fix(#4249): pin platform in X_OK-testing entries so they're deterministic cross-CI-runner X_OK is a POSIX-only concept, skipped entirely when an entry's platform is win32 (matching production). Two test entries omitted platform, defaulting to process.platform — on an actual windows-latest CI runner that silently skipped the very check they were meant to exercise, turning 'not-executable' into a false pass. Pin platform: 'linux' so these are deterministic regardless of which OS runs the suite. * fix(#4249): classify EPERM the same as EACCES in statSync error handling Windows raises EPERM (not EACCES) for a parent directory that couldn't be traversed into — was falling through to 'missing', misreporting a genuine permission problem as a nonexistent path. * docs(#4249): address final CodeRabbit doc-completeness findings - CONTEXT.md: install()'s documented result shape omitted configuredEntrypoints; the ConfiguredEntrypoint shape omitted selfExecutable. - docs/how-to/update-gsd.md: the failure-mode sentence omitted unreadable and lacks-execute-permission, which the installer also rejects. * fix(#4249): stop double-validating every configured entrypoint on install/update installAllRuntimes' finalize() already runs assertConfiguredEntrypoints once over the aggregate set; finishInstall then re-ran the identical check per runtime in the printSummaries loop right after, so every entrypoint paid its statSync/accessSync/interpreter-resolution cost twice on every install and update. Add entrypointsAlreadyValidated to skip the redundant pass specifically on that path, while leaving the check intact for any caller that invokes finishInstall directly. * chore(#4154): point changeset pr field at rehearsal fork PR while CI runs there * perf(#4249): memoize interpreter candidate resolution across entrypoints resolveExecutableBinary walked PATH once per (entry, candidate) pair; a typical install has a dozen-plus entries sharing the same few candidate lists (process.execPath for JS hooks, bash for shell hooks). Cache by (platform, candidate) so each distinct pair resolves once per validation call instead of once per entry. * chore(#4249): point changeset pr field at the rebased rehearsal fork PR * fix(#4249): drop entrypoint tracking from the now-dead Codex event writer #2586 (landed on next after this branch forked) removed install.js's CODEX_EXTENDED_HOOK_EVENTS registration loop, so ensureCodexHooksJsonEvent no longer runs during install or update. The ConfiguredEntrypoint records this branch added inside it were therefore unreachable and untested. Restore the function to its upstream shape; the entrypoints it used to report were never collected by any caller. * refactor(#4249): drop the revalidation bypass flag and the candidate cache Both were this PR's own micro-optimisations over a set of roughly a dozen entries. `entrypointsAlreadyValidated` let a caller turn the finishInstall gate off to save one statSync/accessSync pass; `resolvedCandidateCache` memoised resolveExecutableBinary across entries that are already deduped by (configPath, scriptPath). Neither is measurable, and the flag was the only way to reach finishInstall with validation disabled. finishInstall now always validates what it is given. * chore(#4249): point the changeset pr field back at the upstream PR * refactor(#4249): track settings.json entrypoints without the hooksSurface gate The install-surface writer only tracked configured entrypoints when the runtime's descriptor also declared `hooksSurface: 'settings-json'`. Nothing asserts that axis agrees with `installSurface`, so a descriptor that broke the coupling would silently pass `configuredEntrypoints: undefined` and drop that runtime out of the validation this PR adds — reintroducing the exact 'reports Done! over a broken entrypoint' failure #4154 exists to close. Remove the dependence rather than test it: everything recorded on this path lands in settings.json by construction, and the registered-command filter already discards entries no persisted hook references. * chore(#4249): put the changeset body in the documented two-part format CONTRIBUTING.md and .changeset/README.md both show `**<bold change>** — <symptom-led explanation>.`; the fragment was a single unbolded sentence. * chore(#4249): point the changeset pr field at the rehearsal fork PR while CI runs there * fix(#4249): restore the whole manifest-tracked GSD file set on Codex rollback #3245's snapshot covers config.toml, hooks.json, skills/gsd-*, agents/gsd-* and gsd-core/VERSION. The install overwrites every other GSD-owned file too — hooks/, gsd-core/CHANGELOG.md, scripts/, gsd-core/.gsd-runtime, the manifest itself — before the entrypoint-validation gate runs, so a validation failure left the new payload sitting on top of the restored old config. Snapshot the file set the PREVIOUS install's gsd-file-manifest.json claims, before runInstallerMigrations so the bytes are the true pre-install state, and restore it from both Codex rollback closures ahead of the per-surface restores. Files only the failed install introduced are removed, read from the manifest now on disk. The manifest is already the authoritative record of what GSD owns, so no second hand-written list can drift out of sync, and user-owned files are never snapshotted or removed. Every path is confined through resolveInstallRelativePath, so a hand-edited manifest cannot turn rollback into an arbitrary-path write. Non-Codex runtimes are unaffected: the snapshot is gated on the same tomlConfigInstall + non-minimal condition as #3245's. * fix(#4249): keep the managed-file snapshot honest in minimal mode and on a bad manifest Two follow-on defects in the previous commit's snapshot: - The capture was gated on `!isMinimalMode`, copied from #3245. A core/ --minimal Codex install still writes gsd-core/, hooks/, scripts/ and the manifest, and restoreCodexSnapshot is reachable in that mode (#2695), so the snapshot came back empty while the rollback still ran — and its removal pass would have deleted every file the new manifest lists. Gate on tomlConfigInstall alone, matching where the rollback actually reaches. - An unreadable or unparseable prior manifest was caught alongside ENOENT and treated as a fresh install. That is the same empty-snapshot state, so a failed update over a real install with a corrupt manifest could delete its prior payload. Track whether the pre-install GSD-owned set is KNOWN: ENOENT means known-empty; any other read error or a parse failure means unknown, and the restore closure returns without touching anything, degrading to #3245's narrower rollback. Deliberately not fatal — a corrupt manifest has to stay repairable by reinstalling over it. Both paths are covered by red-checked regression tests. * fix(#4249): snapshot Codex skills, agents and VERSION in minimal mode too commit removed from the manifest snapshot. restoreCodexSnapshot is reachable for a core/--minimal install (#2695), and its pass-2 sweeps remove every gsd-* skill dir and gsd-* agent file the snapshot does not claim — so with an empty minimal-mode snapshot a rollback deleted the whole skills/agents surface with nothing to restore it from. Codex resolves skills to $HOME/.agents/skills via the ADR-1239 skills-kind home override, so this is also the reason manifest `skills/` keys do not resolve under configDir: that surface belongs to this snapshot, not to the manifest-driven one. Gate on tomlConfigInstall alone. _codexPreConfigRollback stays null in minimal mode — doing nothing on an early failure is the non-destructive side. Covered by a red-checked regression test that plants bytes in an alternate-home skill file, reinstalls under the core profile marker, and asserts the rollback restores it. * fix(#4249): never remove on rollback unless a prior manifest proves what predates the install Three defects in the manifest-driven Codex rollback, all in its removal half: - ENOENT marked the snapshot usable, arming the removal pass on a FIRST install. GSD may have overwritten a user's file at a manifest-tracked path there, and no prior manifest records the difference — so rollback deleted it where before it merely left it overwritten. Absent, unreadable and malformed manifests now all leave the prior set UNKNOWN and skip removal entirely. - Membership was tested against the map of files whose pre-install read SUCCEEDED, so a tracked file that existed but was unreadable read as introduced-by-this-install and was removed. Track the prior manifest's paths in their own Set and test against that. - The unreachable "delete the manifest when there was no prior one" branch is gone: usable now implies a parsed prior manifest. Also adds the end-to-end test the aggregate gate was missing — the four Codex rollback tests drove the closure directly, proving the restore but not the wiring. installAllRuntimes(['codex','cline']) under an emptied PATH makes Cline's `env node` entry fail validation for real, and asserts Codex's payload comes back. Test preamble (HOME/USERPROFILE sandbox + config-env scrub) is now one helper instead of six copies. Both new tests are red-checked. * test(#4249): use unlinkSync, not rmSync, to drop the manifest in a test lint:ci's raw-fs.rmSync rule points tests at helpers.cleanup for its Windows-EBUSY retry budget. That budget is for directory trees; this removes a single file, which unlinkSync says more precisely and the rule does not flag. * chore(#4249): point the changeset pr field back at the upstream PR * fix(#4249): use an unambiguous dedup key and surface partial-restore failures trek-e's 2026-09-08 adversarial pass flagged two findings in the new entrypoint-validation/rollback code: - assertConfiguredEntrypoints' dedup key already used a raw NUL separator (introduced in ceebb65f2d), but git/Read render NUL as a space, so the key looked like a plain-space join to every reviewer that read the diff. Replace it with JSON.stringify([configPath, scriptPath]) so the separator is visible and unambiguous. - restoreManagedFileSnapshot's per-file restore catch block claimed to 'surface the original error' but only swallowed it, matching (and widening) the pre-existing #3245 restoreCodexSnapshot pattern. Add an actual console.warn using the existing best-effort-warning convention, scoped to just this PR's new function. * fix(#4249): treat a files-less prior manifest as unknown, not known-empty agy's gemini-3.8-flash-high adversarial pass (round 5) found and I reproduced empirically: a structurally-valid manifest missing the files key (e.g. {"version":1}) parses without throwing, so Object.keys(undefined || {}) silently read as 'zero files predate this install' instead of the UNKNOWN state the malformed-manifest guard exists to produce. Rollback's removal pass then deleted every GSD-owned file the failed install's own manifest listed, including ones that predated it — the exact data loss the #4249 CodeRabbit malformed-manifest fix was supposed to prevent, reachable through a JSON.parse success instead of a failure. Route the shapeless case into the same catch-all UNKNOWN path via an explicit shape check. Regression test reproduces the deletion before the fix and confirms the file survives after it. Also extend restoreManagedFileSnapshot's removal-pass rmSync and final manifest-rewrite catches with the same real console.warn trek-e's round-4 review asked for on the per-file restore catch — same rollback function, same operator-facing-signal gap. * docs(#4249): correct which runtimes actually leave a written config on rollback agy's completeness audit (round 5, holistic pass) caught this new paragraph claiming 'for every other runtime, the configuration file(s) already written during that update are left in place' — false for Claude Code and other settings.json-based runtimes, whose write never happens on failure (assertConfiguredEntrypoints runs before finishInstall's writeSettings). Only Cursor/Windsurf/Kimi/Cline actually match that description, since they persist their config file inside install() ahead of the gate. Split the one sentence into the three actual outcomes; matches the PR body's own accurate Before/After wording, which this doc addition had drifted from. * fix(#4249): clean up doc/comment mismatches and dead fields from opus review Opus critical-code-reviewer + ponytail-review pass on the final diff: - assertConfiguredEntrypoints carried finishInstall's old docblock ("Apply statusline config, then print completion message") from before this function was inserted between comment and callee. finishInstall already has its own accurate #4249 comment, so the stale docblock is removed rather than moved. - checked: number on ConfiguredEntrypointValidationResult and error.configuredEntrypointValidation on the thrown error: the first had zero consumers anywhere in the repo, including its own defining file, and is removed. The second matches an existing repo convention (bin/install.js's installerMigrationRollbackFailures, #4249 predates this PR) of attaching structured diagnostic context to a re-thrown Error even before a consumer exists, so it's kept. - finishInstall's own assertConfiguredEntrypoints call is a redundant backstop on the real production path (installAllRuntimes's aggregate call already validates the superset first), but its comment read as though this call alone provided the before-the-write guarantee. Clarified rather than removed — it's the only gate for a caller that invokes finishInstall directly. * chore(#4249): split the manifest-driven rollback engine out into #4544 Issue #4154 asked the installer to consume a validation failure "through the existing rollback mechanism, without a second transaction mechanism". The manifest-driven rollback widening added during review (capture every path the prior gsd-file-manifest.json claims, restore those bytes, remove what only the failed install introduced) is that second mechanism on a plain reading. It is a real fix for a #3245-era gap, but an independent one, so it moves to its own bug report and PR. Removed here: - bin/install.js: the pre-install managed-file capture block and restoreManagedFileSnapshot, plus its call sites in _codexPreConfigRollback and restoreCodexSnapshot (99 lines). - tests/configured-entrypoint-validation.test.cjs: the five tests that exercise the manifest engine. - CONTEXT.md and docs/how-to/update-gsd.md: the sentences describing the widened restore. update-gsd.md again documents the #3245 surfaces only. Kept, because it is #4154's own scope: - the entrypoint-validation gate itself; - Codex's install() result binding rollbackInstallerMigrations to restoreCodexSnapshot (config.toml, hooks.json, skills/gsd-*, agents/gsd-*, gsd-core/VERSION); - the !isMinimalMode gate removal on that snapshot. Binding the closure to the result made it reachable for a core/--minimal install, where its pass-2 sweeps delete every gsd-* skill dir and agent file the snapshot does not claim; an empty minimal-mode snapshot therefore deleted the whole surface with nothing to restore. The surviving aggregate-failure test now asserts on config.toml, a surface the #3245 snapshot owns, instead of gsd-core/CHANGELOG.md, which only the manifest engine restored. Refs #4544 * test(#4249): cover configured entrypoints through the packed install path #4154's scope lists install smoke coverage alongside the installer gate — "assert representative configured entrypoints resolve for supported runtime profiles". The gate itself (assertConfiguredEntrypoints / validateConfiguredEntrypoints) is unit-covered by in-process install() calls; nothing proved the property survives npm pack -> npm install -g -> install.js. Add Cycle 4 to runSmoke. For each of claude and codex — the two distinct config surfaces GSD writes launch paths into (settings.json, and hooks.json + config.toml) — run the tarball-installed installer into a throwaway HOME, then re-read that runtime's own written config and return the new ENTRYPOINT_UNRESOLVED code when a script path it names does not resolve to a file. install-smoke.yml already asserts .code == "ok" on the CLI, so the check becomes a release gate on every matrix host without workflow changes. The scan re-derives paths from the written config instead of reusing the installer's own entrypoint list, and test I shows why that matters: a registration the installer never touched during a run is invisible to the in-process gate, so the install exits 0 and only reading the config back off disk catches the dangling launch path. * ci(#4249): pack a publish-shaped tarball in the install smoke lane `npm pack` runs prepack/prepare (build:lib); only prepublishOnly runs build:hooks. hooks/dist is gitignored, so the tarball install-smoke.yml packs after `npm ci` carries no hook scripts at all — the lane has been smoking a package that differs from the published one in exactly the artifacts the lifecycle smoke is supposed to launch. That went unnoticed because the lane's init runs `--local`, which registers no statusline and therefore registers no hook whose target is missing. A `--global` install on the same tarball exits 1 on #4249's own gate (`gsd-statusline.js (missing)`), which is what the new configured-entrypoint cycle performs, so without this step the cycle would report INIT_FAILED instead of checking anything. Build hooks before packing so the smoked tarball matches prepublishOnly. The CLI now reports 16 configured entrypoints for claude and 1 for codex instead of zero. * fix(#4249): scope Codex's full snapshot restore to entrypoint failures Binding Codex's result to `restoreCodexSnapshot` made ANY finalize-stage exception un-install a Codex install that had already succeeded and already printed its own "Done!" summary — `rollbackFinalizedInstallerMigrations` wraps the whole `finalize()` body, not just the aggregate `assertConfiguredEntrypoints` call. Nothing documents that. `docs/installer-migrations.md#phase-4-installupdate-integration` scopes finalize-stage rollback to installer *migrations* ("the executor uses the journal to restore modified paths"), and this PR's own operator-facing paragraph in `docs/how-to/update-gsd.md` scopes the Codex config.toml/hooks.json/skills/ agents/VERSION revert to entrypoint-validation failures specifically ("If a script is missing, unreadable, ... For Codex, this reverts ..."). The wide behaviour is also incoherent as a transaction abort: the same doc says Cursor, Windsurf, Kimi and Cline keep the config they wrote inside install(). Concretely: `installAllRuntimes(['codex', 'kilo'])` where Kilo's finishInstall hits EACCES writing kilo.json rolled Codex's config.toml back to its pre-install bytes — on an update, silently downgrading a working Codex install to the previous version while the user had just been told it was Done. Select the rollback by error kind instead. `assertConfiguredEntrypoints` already tags its error with `configuredEntrypointValidation`, so the full snapshot restore runs for that error (and anything downstream of it, including finishInstall's per-runtime backstop) and the installer-migrations-only closure runs for everything else. The codex result now also exposes that narrow closure as `rollbackInstallerMigrationsOnly`; `rollbackInstallerMigrations` keeps meaning the full restore, so the direct-call contract asserted by tests/codex-config.test.cjs is unchanged. Adds a regression test that installs codex+kilo together, injects EACCES on the Kilo permission write by monkeypatching node:fs (restored in a finally — never chmod 0o000, which root bypasses in CI), and asserts Codex's config.toml keeps the bytes the successful install wrote. Verified red against the pre-fix unconditional path. Cline cannot host this test: its plan is writesSharedSettings:false + finishPermissionWriter:null, so its finishInstall performs no write and has no non-entrypoint failure path. Kilo's configureKiloPermissions runs unconditionally (unlike OpenCode's, it is not GSD_TEST_MODE-gated) and ends in an unguarded fs.writeFileSync. * docs(#4249): sync CONTEXT.md's rollback description with the round-6 narrowing CONTEXT.md still described Codex's rollback as an unconditional bind to restoreCodexSnapshot after ff13adc00 scoped it to entrypoint- validation failures via rollbackInstallerMigrationsOnly and the configuredEntrypointValidation error tag. Caught during the round-6 PR body pass. * fix(#4249): stop rollbackInstallerMigrations meaning its own opposite Codex's install() result bound `rollbackInstallerMigrations` to restoreCodexSnapshot (the FULL pre-install snapshot restore) and put the actual installer-migrations-only closure behind `rollbackInstallerMigrationsOnly` — so for one runtime the unsuffixed name meant the opposite of what it says, and CONTEXT.md had to concede as much in prose. Invert it: `rollbackInstallerMigrations` is the narrow closure for every runtime, matching both its name and the meaning it already has on next, and the snapshot restore gets its own Codex-only field, `rollbackPreInstallSnapshot`. The selection in rollbackFinalizedInstallerMigrations collapses to one line and no longer needs a fallback chain. Also in this commit, all against the same rollback path: - Correct the rollbackFinalizedInstallerMigrations comment. It read as if the round-6 narrowing prevented any sibling-triggered revert of a Codex install the user has already seen "Done!" for. It does not, and is not meant to: `wide` is true for ANY entrypoint-validation error from ANY runtime, because the aggregate gate is all-or-nothing — an invalid Cline entrypoint reverts Codex's snapshot, which tests/configured-entrypoint-validation.test.cjs's 'an aggregate entrypoint validation failure rolls the Codex install back (#4249)' asserts directly. The discriminator is the error's KIND, not which runtime owns the failing path. Comment and CONTEXT.md now say that. - Name the runtime in the "Configured entrypoint validation failed" error. ConfiguredEntrypointInvalid already carries `runtime`; the message threw it away, leaving an operator of a multi-runtime install unable to tell whose entrypoint broke — which matters precisely because the failure can revert a runtime that was itself fine. - Set `configuredEntrypoints: []` explicitly on the copilot-instructions early return. Every other branch states the key; this one relied on installAllRuntimes' `(result.configuredEntrypoints || [])` defence. `[]` is correct, not a workaround: every Copilot hook is an inline printf one-liner (GSD_COPILOT_*_HOOK_BASH/PWSH), so there is no GSD-managed script or interpreter to resolve. No behaviour change beyond the error-message text. * docs(#4249): narrow the smoke scan's config-surface claim to what it checks RUNTIME_CONFIG_FILES claimed every GSD-managed executable a runtime is told to launch is registered in one of settings.json / hooks.json / config.toml, and that nothing else in a config dir is runtime configuration. Both halves are false as stated. Cline registers its hook at .clinerules/hooks/PreToolUse — a subdirectory, and not one of those names (writeClineArtifacts, src/runtime-hooks-surface.cts). Kimi's native [[hooks]] config.toml lives under resolveKimiHooksTomlDir() (~/.kimi), a directory separate from Kimi's own GSD configDir — the same gap installer-migration 007 already documents as structurally unreachable. The scan is in fact correct for what it runs against: entrypointRuntimes defaults to claude + codex, whose launch paths do all live in those three top-level files. Restate the docstring at that scope, name the two known out-of-scope surfaces, and warn that adding either runtime to entrypointRuntimes without teaching scanConfiguredEntrypoints about its surface yields a scan that finds zero entrypoints and proves nothing. The entrypointRuntimes default comment carried the same overgeneralization ("every other runtime reuses one of them") and is corrected with it. Documentation only; no code change. * fix(#4249): complete configuredEntrypoints/rollback shape on unparseable settings.local.json An internal adversarial review (agy/gemini-3.8-flash-medium, round 8) found that install()'s settings-json early return for an unparseable settings.local.json omitted configuredEntrypoints and rollbackInstallerMigrations from its result, unlike every other branch. rollbackFinalizedInstallerMigrations reads result.rollbackInstallerMigrations unconditionally, so this branch silently dropped its own installer-migration rollback on a later finalize-stage failure. Completed the return shape: configuredEntrypoints: [] (matching Copilot's equally-early no-entrypoints-yet return) and rollbackInstallerMigrations (already in closure scope). Red-then-green regression test added. * test(#4249): ensure hooks/dist before packing in release-tarball-smoke.install.test.cjs Same internal adversarial review (round 8): this suite's before() packed the tarball directly, without the ensureHooksDist() guard every sibling install-test suite (install.test.cjs, install-minimal-hooks.test.cjs, mcp-catalog-parity.install.test.cjs) already uses. On a clean tree, or run in isolation ahead of a suite that builds hooks/dist itself, this suite's pack would ship a tarball with no hook scripts and fail closed on SMOKE.INIT_FAILED instead of testing anything. * fix(#4249): refresh stale test-timings weight for the codex-config split next's own consolidation split (#4139/#4540) moved tests/codex-config.test.cjs's heavy install()-pipeline blocks into tests/codex-config-hooks.test.cjs, but the CI shard packer's weight table (tests/test-timings.json) was never updated: codex-config.test.cjs still carried its pre-split weight (127783ms, ~18x the suite mean), and codex-config-hooks.test.cjs — which now holds the #3245 block this PR extends with its own #4249 install()-pipeline test — had no entry at all, so the packer would silently underestimate it at the table's median weight (roughly a 9x underestimate against its real cost). trek-e's most recent review flagged a Windows shard timeout in-flight on codex-config.test.cjs, plausibly aggravated by this PR's own addition to that file before the rebase moved it. Re-measured both files locally (node --test --test-reporter=tap, max of 3 runs, matching the table's own max-across-streams methodology) and patched just these two entries — not a full regeneration, which would need real multi-lane CI data this session doesn't have access to. * fix(#4249): register configured-entrypoint-validation tests in the conformance-tier lists next's platform-conformance-tier classifier (#4591/#4598) landed after this branch's last rebase, so tests/configured-entrypoint-validation.test.cjs and tests/codex-config-hooks.test.cjs were never classified, failing lint:ci's gen-platform-conformance-tier --check and both the Linux and macOS conformance suites. * fix(#4249): drop codex-config.test.cjs from the #4733 pinned isolated-set expectation next's #4733 (landed after this branch's last rebase) replaced the static ISOLATED_HEAVY_FILES set with a threshold derived live from tests/test-timings.json, and pins the current derived result in EXPECTED_ISOLATED_UNIT_FILES for regression coverage. That pinned list still named codex-config.test.cjs, whose own weight this PR already dropped from 127783ms to 189ms (after splitting its heavy install()-pipeline blocks into codex-config-hooks.test.cjs) — well under #4733's derived 120000ms bar. The live-computed set correctly no longer includes it; the pinned expectation is updated to match. * fix(#4249): name the rollback consequence in the entrypoint-validation error, and prove Cline's file survives it trek-e's review flagged two Major gaps: the thrown error read identically regardless of which of three real outcomes a runtime hit (nothing persisted / snapshot reverted / config left broken on disk), and no test proved the disclosed "left on disk, unreverted" case for Cursor/Windsurf/ Kimi/Cline — only Codex's revert path was ever asserted. assertConfiguredEntrypoints now tags each invalid entry with its actual consequence, mirrored from docs/how-to/update-gsd.md's existing rollback-matrix disclosure. A new test drives the same aggregate failure through Cline (whose own entrypoint is the one that fails) and asserts its hook file is still on disk afterward. * fix(#4249): close 4 gaps antigravity's adversarial review found in the entrypoint-validation PR One review pass (gemini-3.8-flash-high via the antigravity review lane) against this PR's full diff against next, findings independently verified against source before fixing: - Copilot's install() return object was the only one of 6 runtime branches missing rollbackInstallerMigrations — reachable now that this PR's own aggregate gate runs rollback across every result on any runtime's entrypoint failure, not just Copilot's own. - buildHookCommand's unresolved-bash early return skipped track() entirely, so a win32 install with no Git Bash silently produced an unregistered .sh hook instead of the 'unresolved-interpreter' validation failure configuredEntrypointsForHook's own comment said it would. - release-tarball-smoke.cjs reported a Cycle 4 install failure under SMOKE.INIT_FAILED (Cycle 1's code) instead of the already-existing SMOKE.INSTALL_FAILED. - SCRIPT_PATH_RE excluded whitespace to avoid swallowing a shell command's trailing args, which also truncated any configDir containing a space (e.g. a real "/Users/John Doe/.claude"), silently zeroing the scan. Anchored the match on the already-known configDir prefix instead of a generic absolute-path guess: removes the ambiguity outright rather than patching the character class, and stays a raw-text scan on purpose (it catches a writer that emits a path without registering it — a JSON.parse of the expected schema would miss exactly that case). One suggested finding (test-timings.json "missing" the new test file) was verified false — that table only holds measured CI timings, populated after a file's first real run — and one Ponytail suggestion (a JSON.stringify dedup key) was rejected as it would reintroduce a real, if narrow, key-collision risk for no benefit. * fix(#4249): fix fork CI red from a stale changeset pr field and an unquoted docs/ comment changeset-lint requires pr: to match the PR it runs on (16 on the fork, not the eventual upstream number) — rehearsal-branch convention already established earlier in this PR's history. lint-docs-guard-registration's quote-pairing heuristic doesn't require the docs/ path itself to be quoted — it flags a file once ANY quote-delimited span containing "docs/" appears anywhere in it, alongside any real fs read call. A comment ending "...update-gsd.md's rollback-matrix paragraph" supplied the closing quote character (the possessive apostrophe) the heuristic paired with an unrelated single-quoted string earlier in the file. Reworded to avoid the unquoted apostrophe next to the path. * chore(#4249): point the changeset pr field back at the upstream PR Fork rehearsal (PR #16) is green; the real target for this changeset is upstream PR #4249. --------- Co-authored-by: Test <test@test.com> Co-authored-by: Tom Boucher <trekkie@nomorestars.com> |
||
|
Zy Deng
|
4c60879b5d |
fix(#4132): verify durable runtime surface sources (#4182)
* fix(#4132): verify durable runtime surface sources * chore(#4132): record PR number in changeset * test(#4132): cover rejected commands source alias * fix(#4132): reject aliased package fallback * test(#4132): cover rejected agents source alias * test(#4132): cover partially aliased marker provider * fix(#4132): reject partially aliased source providers * test(#4132): cover routed source identity probes * fix(#4132): route installed source identity probes * refactor(#4132): tighten installer source metadata * test(#4132): cover corpus trust boundary attacks * fix(#4132): close installed corpus trust gaps * refactor(#4132): keep installer authority private * fix(#4132): preserve private installer fallback * test(#4132): preserve fixture source authority * fix(#4132): reject overlapping source fallback * fix(#4132): avoid redundant installed corpus reads * refactor(#4132): simplify provider resolution * test(#4132): sync install tree fixtures after rebase --------- Co-authored-by: Tom Boucher <trekkie@nomorestars.com> |
||
|
Tom Boucher
|
3fac6e629f |
test(#3145): bound the installer/runtime cluster onto the process seam (#3176)
* test(#3145): bound the installer/runtime cluster onto the process seam Migrates 156 unbounded sync spawn sites across 47 files. Allowlist 120 to 73. Timeouts are sized from evidence already in the tree rather than a house default, because this wave spawns installers rather than git plumbing and an undersized bound does not catch a hang -- it manufactures CI flake, which is worse, since a flake gets re-run instead of investigated. install.test.cjs records a real spawnSync ETIMEDOUT at a 60000ms cap on a loaded bench while another lane passed the same commit in 12.7s, so full installs are bound at 120000ms against that recorded incident. Also adds an auditable escape to the guard's timeout ceiling. The 600000ms cap was set in #3143 from partial evidence, but fragment-single-edit- propagation carries a documented, load-tested 900000ms bound on a run that chains a full build plus eight generators -- the guard would have rejected a correct timeout the moment that file left the allowlist. A value above the ceiling is now permitted only with an inline allow-spawn-timeout-ceiling marker carrying a non-empty reason. It raises the ceiling; it never waives the requirement for a bound, which is asserted directly. install-shared.cjs keeps its hand-rolled assert rather than routing through throwIfFailed: its message embeds both streams, and throwIfFailed carries only a trimmed stderr. The message now also names the outcome, so a bounded timeout reads as such across its 38 importers instead of as expected null to equal 0. * test(#3145): extract class-norm timeouts and correct the build-hooks sizing A pre-PR review found 52 copies of four class-norm timeout constants across this wave. These are not per-suite fixture bindings -- they are shared facts about how long a class of subprocess takes, derived from a recorded bench incident. That norm already moved once (60000 to 120000 after a real ETIMEDOUT), and 52 copies would have drifted the next time it moved. Extracts tests/helpers/timeouts.cjs, where each norm is justified once, and converts the copies. A site that genuinely differs -- a real tsc compile, or regen:derived -- keeps its own local constant with its own justification. Also corrects a misclassification: scripts/build-hooks.js was sized as a build at 120000 in twelve places and 60000 in another, but it compiles and bundles nothing. Its own header says no bundling needed; it copies pre-built files and syntax-checks them with vm. Three different values bounded one script; now there is one. * test(#3145): fix red CI — lint self-match and a Windows chunk overrun Two failures on PR 3176. lint-allow-test-rule-refs read a RuleTester fixture as a real exemption. The fixture exists to prove an unrelated marker does NOT suppress the rule, so it carries that marker's literal text as test data. Split via concatenation, the same idiom no-unbounded-spawn-allowlist.test.cjs already uses for its own self-match problem. The explanatory comment needed the same treatment. The Windows shard 3/3 chunk was killed at its 600000ms budget. Output stopped seven minutes before the kill, so this was an overrun rather than a slow chunk: regenDerivedPropagatesSingleFragmentEditWithNoSecondSourceSurface runs regen:derived bounded at 900000ms, which is larger than the whole chunk budget, so the chunk killer always fires first and it can never complete there. Both the test and that bound predate this change; modifying the file pulled it into the Windows targeted set and exposed it. Skipped on Windows with the reason recorded; the Linux lanes cover it. The 900000 bound and its ceiling marker are unchanged -- they are correct. * test(#3145): refresh the stale test-timings cost table The Windows shard was killed at its 600000ms per-chunk budget. run-tests.cjs packs chunks by measured duration from tests/test-timings.json, and an unknown file falls back to the table's median weight -- advisory by design, but it silently underweights exactly the files that matter. Four of the failing chunk's 22 files were absent from the table, including the two heaviest: fragment-single-edit-propagation.install.test.cjs at 230s (it runs regen:derived) and agent-fragments-emission.install.test.cjs at 79s. Both were weighted as average, so the chunk's total weight read 53.68 against a budget of 60 and the packer produced a single chunk. Regenerated from a passing full-suite run, per the remedy the script itself documents. 700 to 770 entries, 70 added, 0 dropped -- verified, since gen-test-timings.cjs replaces the table wholesale rather than merging. Proven against the real packer: the same 22 files now weigh 103.91 and split into two chunks. No logic, budget, or timeout was changed; raising a budget to make a red gate pass is not a fix. --------- Co-authored-by: sim <sim@local> |
||
|
Tom Boucher
|
f6257f3745 |
ci(#2952): shard the full test lane instead of widening its cap (#2960)
* ci(#2952): budget CI job timeouts by headroom over measured cost `origin/next` was red. The only failing check was `Required tests`, and its sole cause was `test (ubuntu-latest, 24)` reported `cancelled` — GitHub's conclusion for a job that exceeds its `timeout-minutes`, not a button press. That job's `ubuntu-latest / 24` entry is the only `scope: full` matrix entry: it runs the whole unit suite under c8 coverage, then the scripts/ coverage floor, integration, security, install and slow, serially on one runner. On next@5a0a9f097 it ran 15m16s against `timeout-minutes: 15` and was axed 23s into `npm run test:slow`. Projected to a completed slow step (27s on the last green run) the lane costs ~15m20s. Confirmed hypothesis: the budget, not the suite. The lane had been riding the ceiling all day — 12m03s, 11m34s, 11m50s, 14m25s, 14m51s — and crossed on three of the last four full-lane runs ( |
||
|
Tom Boucher
|
c5e0371775 |
feat(#1951): reversibility tagging — gate one-way-door decisions (#2471)
* test(#1951): add failing-first tests for reversibility tagging Red phase for issue #1951 (reversibility tagging: classify decisions by undo cost, gate one-way doors behind a checkpoint:decision). Tests assert, per the issue's acceptance criteria: - discuss-phase CONTEXT.md template records a **Reversibility:** field with a rationale on captured decisions, and states it is optional - gsd-planner @-references planner-reversibility.md and stays under the 49152-char agent cap (LARGE_CAP, tests/agent-size-budget.test.cjs) - a one-way rating inserts a checkpoint:decision before the dependent task; reversible inserts none; costly is flagged but never blocks - the taxonomy defaults to reversible when unsure (checkpoint-fatigue guard) and inserting a checkpoint implies autonomous: false - docs/reference/plan-md.md documents <reversibility> as optional with all three ratings - --no-reversibility-gates parses to REVERSIBILITY_GATES=false, is injected into the planner prompt, and is advertised in the command argument-hint and help full mode (argument-hint parity) - the override suppresses the gate but still persists the rating - cmdVerifyPlanStructure accepts every rating and the absent case (additive-validator guarantee, behavioral via runGsdTools) - parity: thinking-models-planning.md #4 adopts the canonical three-level taxonomy and the binary REVERSIBLE/IRREVERSIBLE vocabulary is gone - no content loss from the planner extraction made to fit under the cap Prose-contract assertions are Red until the implementation lands. The behavioral validator assertions pass immediately — regression guards proving the validator already accepts unknown optional tags. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com> * feat(#1951): reversibility tagging — gate one-way-door decisions Classify planning decisions by what undoing them would cost, and give a one-way door a human beat before the agent walks through it (issue #1951, The Pragmatic Programmer Topic 15 'Reversibility'; Bezos's one-way/two-way door framing). Acceptance criteria met: - discuss-phase records an optional reversibility rating with a rationale on <decisions> entries in the phase CONTEXT.md template. Unrated decisions are treated as reversible, so existing phases are unaffected. - a one-way rating makes gsd-planner insert a checkpoint:decision before the task that implements the decision, reusing the existing checkpoint mechanism -- no new checkpoint machinery. - reversible ratings trigger no checkpoint; costly ratings are flagged in the plan but never block. - the rating persists on the task as the optional <reversibility rating=> element. cmdVerifyPlanStructure accepts every rating and the absent case; the structural validator does not reject unknown optional tags. - --no-reversibility-gates (REVERSIBILITY_GATES=false) suppresses checkpoint insertion for intentionally-unattended runs while still recording ratings -- the override changes what stops the run, not what the plan remembers. Single taxonomy, not two: references/thinking-models-planning.md #4 already shipped a binary REVERSIBLE/IRREVERSIBLE classification and is loaded by both gsd-planner and gsd-plan-checker. It is rewritten onto the canonical three-level vocabulary and now points at planner-reversibility.md as the taxonomy owner, with a parity test that fails if the surfaces diverge (DEFECT.GENERATIVE-FIX-DIVERGENCE). agents/gsd-planner.md sat 47 chars under the 49152 LARGE_CAP, so the checkpoint DO/DON'T guidance was relocated verbatim into planner-antipatterns.md -- already @-referenced from the same section for the same topic, so the planner still loads it and nothing was dropped. A test guards the relocation against content loss. Files: gsd-core/references/planner-reversibility.md (NEW, canonical taxonomy + emission rules + anti-patterns), gsd-planner.md, plan-phase workflow/command/help (flag wiring + parity), plan-md.md schema, discuss-phase context template, CONTEXT.md glossary, INVENTORY + manifest, size baselines, install goldens, plugin skills regen, changeset. Closes #1951 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(#1951): address orthogonal review findings Two isolated reviewers (correctness + security), neither of which authored the change. Every finding fixed: Security — the rationale is untrusted input (ADR-1577). It originates in conversation and flows CONTEXT.md -> planner -> PLAN.md -> executor, each hop an LLM reading the previous hop's output, with no validation on the path. planner-reversibility.md and the discuss-phase template now state it is data and never instructions, and name the </reversibility> early-termination hazard explicitly -- a rationale that closes its own element injects sibling structure the executor reads as real tasks. Four tests guard it. Correctness 1 — nothing machine-enforced the feature's own promise: a task rated one-way with no preceding checkpoint:decision validated as fully clean, so a planner error silently reopened the gap this feature exists to close. cmdVerifyPlanStructure now warns on an ungated one-way rating. A warning, not an error: <reversibility> stays additive and the plan stays valid. Four tests cover ungated (warns), gated (silent), still-valid, and reversible/costly never flagged. Correctness 2 — pass-always test. The --no-reversibility-gates parse test substring-matched the whole workflow file, and plan-phase.md prose mentions both tokens in one sentence, so it passed with the bash conditional deleted: it was testing the documentation, not the parser. Now scoped to the fenced bash blocks and matched as one physical line, with a negative control confirming prose alone cannot satisfy it. Correctness 3 — costly had no itemized emission rule, only one-way did, so two agents could diverge on whether to tag costly at all. Correctness 4 — template convention break: the example ratings were bare while every sibling field uses [...] to signal substitution, inviting an LLM to copy one-way/costly forward as boilerplate. Now bracketed. Correctness 5 — latent false-green: .includes('reversible') also matches inside irreversible/irreversibility, which appear in anti-pattern prose, so a surface that dropped the real taxonomy entry would still pass. Now word-boundary matched. ADR-857 phase-6 ceiling — the first gsd-test run caught plan-phase.md 1216 bytes over its frozen 94519 ceiling (it had 49 bytes of headroom on next). The ceiling may only rise for privileged host machinery, and reversibility gating is optional-feature logic, so the wiring was slimmed to its minimum and the explanatory prose moved to the reference files the planner already loads. plan-phase.md is now 94400 bytes -- 119 under the ceiling and 70 bytes SMALLER than on next, so the host loop shrank while gaining the feature, which is what phase 6 ratchets toward. The tracer contract (tests/tracer-bullet.test.cjs) is unchanged. Lint — fixed an unnecessary non-null assertion in verify.cts and a CRLF-fragile bare \n regex in the new test (DEFECT.WINDOWS-CRLF-TEST- PORTABILITY, the #1658/#1668/#2206/#2449/#2450 class). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(#1951): checkpoint fixture must carry the common task elements The gated-one-way fixture built a checkpoint:decision task from the abbreviated skeleton in gsd-planner.md, which shows only the checkpoint-specific elements (<decision>/<context>/<resume-signal>). cmdVerifyPlanStructure requires <name> and <action> on EVERY task regardless of type, so the fixture failed validation for reasons that had nothing to do with reversibility: errors: ["Task missing <name> element", "Task 'unnamed' missing <action>"] Caught by gsd-test on 14d14a39 (2 failures, both this fixture). The canonical shape is in tests/verify.test.cjs:266 — a checkpoint task carries <name>/<files>/<action>/<verify> like any other. Fixture corrected to match. Verified behaviorally against the real gsd-tools CLI across all four cases: gated one-way (valid, silent), ungated one-way (valid, warns), costly (valid, silent), absent (valid, silent). Not a product defect: the validator's every-task contract is intentional and pre-existing, and docs/reference/plan-md.md scopes its required-element list to type=auto/tracer only because those are the elements a planner must author, not because checkpoints are exempt from <name>. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com> * chore(#1951): backfill changeset pr number to 2471 * fix(#1951): CodeQL incomplete-sanitization + prompt-injection scan collision Both CI failures were real defects in code this PR added, not false positives. CodeQL js/incomplete-sanitization (high), reversibility-tagging.test.cjs:46 — the namesRating helper built its regex with `rating.replace(/[-]/g, '\\-')`, which escapes the hyphen but not backslash, so the escape was incomplete. It was also unnecessary: `-` carries no special meaning outside a character class. Replaced with a complete metacharacter escape (backslash included). Word-boundary behavior verified unchanged across all three ratings — notably that "irreversible" prose still does not satisfy a "reversible" match, which is the false-green this helper exists to prevent. Prompt injection scan — the checkpoint fixture used the human-verification child element inside <verify>. That tag name is a fake-instruction-boundary pattern in scripts/prompt-injection-scan.sh, and the scan runs over changed files, so copying the shape from tests/verify.test.cjs (unflagged only because it is not in this diff) tripped the gate. Switched to the documented plain-prose <verify> form. The first attempt at that fix failed the same gate a second time: the comment explaining the collision quoted the offending tag literally. The comment now names it in prose instead — the scanner does not care whether a match is code or commentary, which is the whole point of the DEFECT.PROMPT-INJECTION-SCAN-COLLISION note in CLAUDE.md. Verified locally before push: scan reports 0 findings across 57 changed files, eslint clean, and both fixtures still validate as designed (gated one-way silent, ungated one-way warns, neither errors). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(#1951): record measured cost and halve gsd-tools spawns The Windows shard 1/3 job timeout was traced to the sharding layer, not to this PR's assertions — see #2472. Two contributing factors were this file's own, and are fixed here. 1. tests/test-timings.json had no entry for reversibility-tagging.test.cjs, so scripts/run-tests.cjs weighted it at the table's median fallback (~315ms) for LPT chunk packing. It actually measures 5595ms — an 18x under-weight. Recorded the measured value from the green gsd-test run (max across the node22/node24 lanes, per gen-test-timings.cjs's convention). Only this one entry: a full regen churns 634 entries of run-to-run drift, and the table is explicitly advisory and un-gated, so a 637-line diff does not belong in a feature PR. 2. Each verifyPlan() spawns gsd-tools, which dominates this file's cost. Spawns cut from 9 to 6 with no coverage lost: - the ungated-one-way warning and its stays-valid assertion now share one plan instead of building the same plan twice; - the reversible/costly never-flagged-as-ungated test was strictly subsumed by the additive suite, which already runs those two ratings ungated and asserts no /reversibilit/ warning at all — and the gate warning's text contains both "reversibility" and "one-way", so the broader assertion catches it. It only re-spawned gsd-tools twice to prove the same thing. Both are symptom fixes. The shard imbalance itself (19/11/10 minutes against a 20-minute cap, from a cost-blind round-robin partition that also reshuffles downstream files whenever one is inserted) is tracked in #2472. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(#1951): checkpoint fixture adopts the #2444 type-branched contract Surfaced by rebasing onto next, which gained #2444 (branch plan-structure validation on task type=checkpoint:*) while this PR was in review. cmdVerifyPlanStructure no longer applies one required-element set to every task. A checkpoint:decision now requires <name> + <resume-signal> + <decision> + <options>, and is exempt from the <action>/<verify>/<done>/ <files> set that auto and tracer tasks carry. The gated-one-way fixture predated that split and failed on the new requirement: errors: ["Task 'Task 0: Confirm the on-disk format' missing <options>"] Fixture rewritten to mirror the checkpoint:decision contract exactly — real <options> with two <option> children — rather than padding it with fields checkpoints no longer need. That also drops the plain-prose <verify> the earlier revision carried purely to dodge the prompt-injection scan; a checkpoint task has no <verify> requirement at all, so the workaround is moot. Verified against the real gsd-tools CLI across all four cases: gated one-way (valid, silent), ungated one-way (valid, warns), costly (valid, silent), absent (valid, silent). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com> |
||
|
Tom Boucher
|
953b8043ea |
fix(#2456): weight test chunks by measured cost and pack with LPT (#2463)
* fix(#2456): weight test chunks by measured cost and pack with LPT scripts/run-tests.cjs guessed each test file's cost from its filename (basename matching /^(?:install|codex-)/ scored 12, everything else 1). Measured durations show that guess is wrong in both directions: installer-migration-authoring.test.cjs scored 12 while running ~0.1s, and the two most expensive files in the suite both scored 1 — run-tests-harness.test.cjs never matched the prefix, and release-tarball-smoke.install.test.cjs was missed because the regex is anchored to the START of the basename. Chunks were therefore balanced by file COUNT, not cost. On the real shard 2/3 the two heaviest files packed into the SAME chunk, leaving the slowest chunk 2.8x the lightest and sitting near the 600s per-chunk timeout while other chunks idled. Weight each file by its measured duration from a checked-in, regenerable timings table and pack with LPT (heaviest first, into the lightest chunk). On the same shard this drops the slowest chunk from 383s to 238s and the imbalance from 2.79x to 1.00x, and separates the two heavy files. Timings are advisory, never gated: an unknown file falls back to the table's median weight, a missing or corrupt table falls back to uniform weight, and a count-based floor guarantees the packer never produces fewer chunks than plain count-based packing would. Closes #2456 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(#2456): harden chunk packing against degenerate knobs and table keys Follow-up hardening found while reviewing the packer, fixed inline. The chunk knobs are read from the environment with Number(), so a typo (RUN_TESTS_MAX_FILES_PER_CHUNK=abc) yields NaN and an explicit 0 yields 0. Both flow into the new chunk-count arithmetic: NaN made Math.ceil return NaN, Array.from({length: NaN}) produce zero bins, and packChunks' retry loop spin forever — a hung CI job with no output. Zero made the count Infinity and threw RangeError: Invalid array length. The previous count-based packer degraded to a single chunk instead, so this was a regression introduced by the LPT rewrite. Normalize the knobs at the environment boundary (positiveNumberEnv: anything not a positive finite number falls back to the default) and guard packChunks itself, since it is exported and cannot assume its caller normalized. Non-finite weights from an arbitrary weightOf are clamped too. RUN_TESTS_CHUNK_TIMEOUT_MS gets the same treatment. Also resolve timing-table lookups with Object.hasOwn: the table is JSON-parsed, so a bare index would walk the prototype chain and return a function for a file named constructor.test.cjs or toString.test.cjs. The typeof guard already rejected that, but the lookup now resolves correctly rather than relying on the downstream check. Refs #2456 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(#2456): correct prototype-lookup rationale and guard generator keys Two findings from independent security review, fixed inline. The makeFileWeigher comment claimed a bare table lookup "would return a FUNCTION for a file named constructor.test.cjs". That premise is false: basename('constructor.test.cjs') is 'constructor.test.cjs', which is not an Object.prototype key, and walkTestFiles only ever collects *.test.cjs. The prototype chain was never reachable from a real selection, and the existing typeof guard already rejected the function it would return, so Object.hasOwn is defense-in-depth rather than a behavior change. The comment now says that instead of asserting something untrue. The accompanying test inherited the same false premise: it fed constructor.test.cjs and asserted a median fallback that would have held with or without the guard, so it passed for a reason unrelated to what it claimed to prove. It now uses BARE keys (constructor, toString, valueOf, hasOwnProperty, __proto__) — the only inputs that actually resolve on Object.prototype — and asserts the real exported contract: any key absent from the table weighs the median, never a function. gen-test-timings.cjs built its output object by computed-key assignment from basenames taken out of a reporter stream it does not control — the js/prototype-polluting-assignment shape, and this repo has a CodeQL barrier for exactly that pattern. It was not exploitable (the value is always a rounded number, so the __proto__ setter is a silent no-op), but it silently DROPPED such an entry rather than reporting it. Validate every key against a test-basename pattern and fail loudly instead, and build the table with a null prototype. Refs #2456 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(#2456): replace tautological chunking tests and clamp chunk count Six findings from independent correctness review, all reproduced and fixed inline. The two subprocess tests written to carry the #2088 guarantee forward were tautological: every seeded file weighed exactly 1, so both passed under the OLD prefix-heuristic packer and with the timings file deleted entirely. Neither could fail for the reason it existed. Both are rebuilt so the old algorithm produces a different packing and the assertion goes red: the spread test now uses three expensive files named so the old heuristic scored them 1 alongside three trivial `install-`-prefixed files it scored 12 — inverted from real cost, giving {2,2,1,1} under the old packer versus {2,2,2} under measured weights. The companion test covers the other direction: four trivial `install-` files the old heuristic split into four single-file chunks now stay in one. packChunks clamped the chunk count from below but not above, so a legitimate but tiny budget (RUN_TESTS_MAX_FILES_PER_CHUNK=1e-9, which positiveNumberEnv accepts) asked for 637,000,000,000 bins and threw RangeError. More chunks than files is never useful; the count now clamps at one file per chunk. The generator's basename-collision guard compared full dirnames, so two OS lanes reporting the same file under different container roots (/work/tests vs C:/work/tests) flagged every shared basename as a collision — on the script's own documented multi-lane usage. Detection is now scoped per stream, where the root is constant; a genuine same-lane collision is still caught. Also: the LPT tie-break compared raw paths, so a path separator (0x2F vs 0x5C) could order a subdir file differently per platform, contradicting the documented byte-identical guarantee — it now normalizes separators. loadTestTimings now honors schema_version instead of writing it and never reading it, falling back to uniform weight on an unknown version. A comment claiming an all-uniform suite "chunks exactly as it did before" was false and contradicted by this PR's own test: the chunk count is preserved, the composition is not. And the missing-table test created a temp dir it never cleaned up, for a path that only needed to not exist. Refs #2456 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com> |