5.4 KiB
5.4 KiB
phase, verified, status, score
| phase | verified | status | score |
|---|---|---|---|
| 16-plan-verification-loop | 2026-01-16T15:30:00Z | passed | 12/12 must-haves verified |
Phase 16: Plan Verification Loop Verification Report
Phase Goal: Add plan verification between planning and execution — planner -> checker -> revise loop Verified: 2026-01-16 Status: passed Re-verification: No — initial verification
Goal Achievement
Observable Truths
| # | Truth | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Plan checker can load PLAN.md files and parse frontmatter | VERIFIED | gsd-plan-checker.md lines 250-302: Step 2-3 document loading PLAN.md files and parsing frontmatter |
| 2 | Plan checker can verify plans against phase goal from ROADMAP.md | VERIFIED | gsd-plan-checker.md lines 253-261: Extracts phase goal from ROADMAP.md |
| 3 | Plan checker returns structured issues or passed status | VERIFIED | gsd-plan-checker.md lines 630-706: ## VERIFICATION PASSED and ## ISSUES FOUND structured returns |
| 4 | Checker output is consumable by orchestrator and planner | VERIFIED | gsd-plan-checker.md lines 569-627: YAML issue structure with plan, dimension, severity, fix_hint |
| 5 | Orchestrator spawns gsd-planner then gsd-plan-checker | VERIFIED | plan-phase.md steps 6 and 8: Task() spawns for gsd-planner then gsd-plan-checker |
| 6 | User sees status between agent spawns | VERIFIED | plan-phase.md lines 94, 174, 225, 263: Display statements between each spawn |
| 7 | If issues found, planner is re-spawned with feedback | VERIFIED | plan-phase.md lines 219-259: Step 10 spawns planner with revision_context containing issues |
| 8 | Loop terminates after max 3 iterations or passed | VERIFIED | plan-phase.md lines 221, 223, 261-271: iteration_count tracking, max 3 check, user options |
| 9 | Planner can accept checker feedback in revision mode | VERIFIED | gsd-planner.md line 842-945: <revision_mode> section accepts <revision_context> with issues |
| 10 | Planner reads existing PLAN.md files when revising | VERIFIED | gsd-planner.md lines 850-861: Step 1 loads existing PLAN.md files |
| 11 | Planner makes targeted updates, not full replan | VERIFIED | gsd-planner.md lines 894-906: DO/DO NOT guidance - "Surgeon, not architect" mindset |
| 12 | Planner returns what changed for user visibility | VERIFIED | gsd-planner.md lines 917-943: Step 6 returns ## REVISION COMPLETE with changes table |
Score: 12/12 truths verified
Required Artifacts
| Artifact | Expected | Status | Details |
|---|---|---|---|
agents/gsd-plan-checker.md |
Plan verification agent (400-600 lines) | VERIFIED | 744 lines, 9 sections (exceeds 7 required), complete methodology |
commands/gsd/plan-phase.md |
Orchestrator with verification loop (200+ lines) | VERIFIED | 310 lines, 11 process steps, planner -> checker -> revise loop |
agents/gsd-planner.md |
Planner with revision mode (1100+ lines) | VERIFIED | 1284 lines, revision_mode section added (~105 lines) |
Key Link Verification
| From | To | Via | Status | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| plan-phase.md | gsd-planner | Task() spawn | WIRED | Lines 147-153, 250-256 |
| plan-phase.md | gsd-plan-checker | Task() spawn | WIRED | Lines 199-205 |
| checker output | planner revision | issues in revision_context | WIRED | Lines 229-247 pass issues to planner |
| gsd-plan-checker | PLAN.md files | Read in verification_process | WIRED | Lines 250-302 load PLAN.md |
| gsd-plan-checker | ROADMAP.md | Phase goal extraction | WIRED | Lines 253-254 extract goal |
| gsd-planner revision | existing PLANs | Read tool | WIRED | Lines 850-856 load existing plans |
| gsd-planner revision | checker issues | revision_context | WIRED | Lines 863-879 parse issue format |
Requirements Coverage
| Requirement | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| gsd-plan-checker agent created | SATISFIED | agents/gsd-plan-checker.md (744 lines) |
| plan-phase.md orchestrates planner -> checker loop | SATISFIED | Steps 6-10 in process section |
| User sees status between agent spawns | SATISFIED | Display statements at each step |
| Checker verifies plans against phase goal | SATISFIED | 6 verification dimensions |
| Planner can revise based on feedback | SATISFIED | <revision_mode> section |
| Loop terminates (max 3 iterations or passed) | SATISFIED | iteration_count tracking |
| Plans verified before execution available | SATISFIED | Complete flow verified |
Anti-Patterns Found
| File | Line | Pattern | Severity | Impact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| - | - | - | - | No anti-patterns found |
No TODO, FIXME, placeholder, or stub patterns detected in any of the three artifacts.
Human Verification Required
None required. All phase deliverables are documentable artifacts (markdown files) that can be fully verified programmatically.
Gaps Summary
No gaps found. All 12 must-have truths verified. All 3 artifacts exist, are substantive (exceed minimum line counts), and are properly wired together. The verification loop is complete:
plan-phase.mdspawnsgsd-planner- Planner creates PLAN.md files
plan-phase.mdspawnsgsd-plan-checker- Checker verifies plans, returns passed or issues
- If issues,
plan-phase.mdspawns planner with revision_context - Planner makes targeted updates (revision_mode)
- Loop repeats up to 3 iterations or until passed
- User sees status throughout
Verified: 2026-01-16 Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier)