msd-core/docs/STATE-MD-LIFECYCLE.md

STATE.md Phase Lifecycle Frontmatter

Status: Read-side shipped in v1.40.0 (issue #2833). parseStateMd() reads the four frontmatter fields below and formatGsdState() renders the in-flight / idle / progress scenes. SDK write-side support to maintain the fields automatically is tracked separately.

GSD's STATE.md carries YAML frontmatter that the status-line hook reads on every render. This document describes the phase-lifecycle fields and the rendering scenes they trigger.

All four lifecycle fields are optional and additive. Existing STATE.md files (without these fields) keep rendering exactly as they did before — no visual change, no migration required.

---

Frontmatter fields

---
gsd_state_version: 1.0
milestone: v2.0                  # existing
milestone_name: Code Quality     # existing
status: in_progress              # existing — see "status semantics" below

# Phase-lifecycle additions (issue #2833) — all optional
active_phase: null               # phase number when an orchestrator is in flight
next_action: execute-phase       # next recommended command when idle
next_phases: ["4.5"]             # phases that next_action applies to (1-2 ids)

progress:                        # nested block (existing key, percent now opt-in for the bar)
  total_phases: 17
  completed_phases: 10
  percent: 59
---

Field reference

Field	Type	When populated	When null/absent
active_phase	string (e.g. "4.5")	An orchestrator command is in flight on this phase	Idle between phases
next_action	string	Idle, with a recommended command (discuss-phase / plan-phase / execute-phase / verify-phase)	An orchestrator is in flight, OR no recommendation available
next_phases	YAML flow array (e.g. ["4.5"])	Goes with next_action — phases the action applies to	Same as above
progress.percent	integer 0-100	Milestone progress in phase dimension (completed_phases / total_phases)	Bar rendering is opt-in — absent → no bar

next_phases parser scope

Only single-line YAML flow is parsed: next_phases: ["4.5", "4.6"].

Block sequences over multiple lines (- 4.5\n - 4.6) are intentionally not parsed — the status-line only needs the primary recommendation, and a single-line array keeps the regex-based parser predictable. If a project needs to track many candidate next phases for documentation purposes, store the extra ones in the STATE.md body.

progress.percent dimension

The bar rendered next to the milestone version reflects phase completion (completed_phases / total_phases), not plan completion.

Plan dimension (completed_plans / total_plans) trends optimistic for any project where future phases haven't been planned yet — total_plans only counts plans inside already-planned phases, so the denominator is structurally smaller than reality. Reporting that number to stakeholders overstates progress.

If a project wants to show plan-level progress somewhere, store it elsewhere in frontmatter or the body — the status-line bar is reserved for the phase-dimension number that matches ROADMAP.md progress tables and MILESTONES.md.

---

Status-line rendering scenes

formatGsdState() checks the lifecycle fields in the order below and emits the first matching scene. If none match, the renderer falls through to the original <status> · <phase> format (byte-for-byte unchanged from v1.38.x).

Scene	Trigger	Display
1. Phase active	active_phase populated	v2.0 [██░░░] X% · Phase 4.5 executing
2. Idle, next recommended	active_phase null AND next_action + next_phases populated	v2.0 [██░░░] X% · next execute-phase 4.5
3. Milestone complete	percent: 100 OR completed_phases == total_phases	v2.0 [██████████] 100% · milestone complete
4. Default fallback	None of the above	v1.9 Code Quality · executing · ph (1/5) (existing format)

Scene priority example

When both active_phase and next_action are populated, Scene 1 wins — an orchestrator is in flight, so any "next recommendation" would be misleading. This is enforced by check order in formatGsdState() and by tests in tests/enh-2833-phase-lifecycle-statusline.test.cjs (suite "scene priority").

Stage labels in Scene 1

In Scene 1, the second part of Phase 4.5 <stage> is whichever value is in the status field at that moment. The convention proposed in issue #2833 is to use the lifecycle stage:

Command	status value while in flight
/gsd-discuss-phase	discussing
/gsd-plan-phase	planning
/gsd-execute-phase	executing
/gsd-verify-work	verifying

If status is left at in_progress (the milestone-level value), Scene 1 renders just Phase 4.5 without the stage suffix.

---

Frontmatter parsing constraints

The status-line hook uses regex-based parsing (no full YAML library), so a few constraints apply:

1. Frontmatter must start at the very first character of the file. Anything (including comments) above the opening --- invalidates the match. The opening --- line must be exactly that — no trailing spaces.

2. Comments inside nested blocks are not supported. The parser for progress: requires the next line to be [ \t]+\w+: — inserting # comment between progress: and the first key breaks the match and the bar disappears. Put any documentation in the body of STATE.md, not inside frontmatter blocks.

3. next_phases accepts only single-line flow format. See the parser scope note above.

These constraints are tested in tests/enh-2833-phase-lifecycle-statusline.test.cjs. If a future change swaps the regex parser for a real YAML library, the constraints can be relaxed and the tests updated accordingly.

---

Backward compatibility

This document describes additive fields. The promise is:

• A STATE.md file with none of the lifecycle fields populated renders byte-for-byte identically to v1.38.x and earlier.
• Adding any lifecycle field is opt-in per project — the renderer falls through to the existing format when fields are absent.
• The progress bar is opt-in even when progress block exists — only progress.percent triggers the bar; total_phases / completed_phases alone don't.

The formatGsdState #2833 backward compatibility test suite locks this guarantee in: any change that breaks legacy STATE.md rendering will fail the suite.

---

Related issues / PRs

• #1989 — enhancement: surface GSD state in statusline. The foundation this proposal extends. Established that STATE.md frontmatter drives the status-line.
• #2833 — enhancement: phase-lifecycle status-line — auto-rotate STATE.md frontmatter as phase orchestrators progress. This document describes the read-side spec from that issue. Write-side SDK / workflow changes to auto-maintain the fields are tracked separately so each piece can be reviewed independently.

Companion read-side issues this proposal also helps close (each fixed a specific symptom of the same gap):

• #1102 — STATE.md frontmatter plan counts only update on plan completion
• #1103 — STATE.md status / last_activity not updated when a phase starts
• #1446 / #1572 — phase complete doesn't update Plans column
• #612 — ROADMAP.md not updating
• #956 — planning document drift across core workflows
• #2018 — verify-work doesn't auto-transition (fixed for verify only)