# Features Research: SummerCMS

**Domain:** Content Management Framework (CMF) for web developers, agencies, and freelancers
**Researched:** 2026-02-04
**Reference:** WinterCMS/OctoberCMS rewrite in Scala
**Confidence:** HIGH (multiple authoritative sources cross-referenced)

## Executive Summary

Modern CMFs in 2025-2026 have converged on a set of table-stakes features while differentiating through API-first architecture, real-time collaboration, and AI-powered capabilities. SummerCMS must nail the fundamentals (plugin system, YAML-driven forms, component architecture) while leveraging Scala's strengths for performance and type safety.

The WinterCMS reference provides a proven plugin architecture with 19 Golem15 plugins demonstrating the feature surface area. Key differentiators for SummerCMS: superior performance, type-safe plugin APIs, and modern frontend integration (Vue + HTMX).

---

## Table Stakes (Must Have)

Features users expect. Missing = product feels incomplete or unusable.

### Content Management

| Feature | Why Expected | Complexity | Notes |
|---------|--------------|------------|-------|
| Page/Post CRUD | Core CMS functionality | Medium | Hierarchical pages, slugs, SEO fields |
| Rich text editor | Content creation baseline | Medium | Recommend headless editor (TipTap/ProseMirror) |
| Media library | Asset management expected | High | Upload, organize, transform images |
| Content versioning | Revision history standard | Medium | Track changes, rollback capability |
| Content scheduling | Publish at future date | Low | Schedule publish/unpublish |
| Draft/Published states | Basic workflow | Low | Minimum viable workflow |

**WinterCMS Reference:** Blog plugin, Pages plugin (Winter.Pages) provide these patterns.

### User & Authentication

| Feature | Why Expected | Complexity | Notes |
|---------|--------------|------------|-------|
| User registration/login | Basic access control | Medium | Email verification, password reset |
| Role-based access (RBAC) | Permission management | High | Roles, permissions, resource scoping |
| Backend admin auth | Separate from frontend users | Medium | Admin accounts with elevated privileges |
| Session management | Security baseline | Low | Secure sessions, logout |
| Password policies | Security compliance | Low | Strength requirements, expiration |

**WinterCMS Reference:** Golem15.User plugin with JWT, GDPR compliance, OAuth integration.

### Admin Backend

| Feature | Why Expected | Complexity | Notes |
|---------|--------------|------------|-------|
| YAML/JSON-driven forms | Core WinterCMS pattern | High | `fields.yaml`, `columns.yaml` equivalent |
| List/table views | Data management | Medium | Sortable, filterable, searchable |
| Form widgets | Extensible inputs | High | Text, dropdown, relation, file, etc. |
| Dashboard | Admin landing page | Low | Widgets, stats, quick actions |
| Settings management | Global configuration | Medium | Type-safe settings with UI |

**WinterCMS Reference:** Backend module, `fields.yaml`/`columns.yaml` pattern, Apparatus form widgets.

### Plugin System

| Feature | Why Expected | Complexity | Notes |
|---------|--------------|------------|-------|
| Plugin installation/removal | Extensibility baseline | High | Package management, migrations |
| Plugin dependencies | Inter-plugin references | Medium | `$require` equivalent |
| Plugin lifecycle hooks | Initialization/boot | Medium | Register, boot, update hooks |
| Database migrations | Schema management | Medium | Per-plugin migrations |
| Asset registration | CSS/JS injection | Low | Backend and frontend asset loading |

**WinterCMS Reference:** Plugin.php with `$require`, `registerComponents()`, `registerSchedule()`.

### Theme System

| Feature | Why Expected | Complexity | Notes |
|---------|--------------|------------|-------|
| Theme installation | Design customization | Medium | Theme packages, activation |
| Layouts/partials | Template composition | Medium | Layout inheritance, partial reuse |
| Template engine | HTML generation | Medium | Twig, Thymeleaf, or Scala templates |
| Asset compilation | Build pipeline | Medium | Vite/Tailwind integration |
| Child themes | Theme extension | Low | Override parent theme files |

**WinterCMS Reference:** CMS module, theme.yaml, layout/page/partial structure.

### Frontend Components

| Feature | Why Expected | Complexity | Notes |
|---------|--------------|------------|-------|
| CMS components | Reusable page elements | High | Similar to WinterCMS components |
| Component parameters | Configuration | Medium | Define via theme/code |
| Partial injection | Dynamic content areas | Low | Placeholders for components |

**WinterCMS Reference:** Component classes with `defineProperties()`, `onRun()` methods.

### Database & ORM

| Feature | Why Expected | Complexity | Notes |
|---------|--------------|------------|-------|
| Model layer | Data abstraction | High | Active Record or Repository pattern |
| Relations | Associations | High | hasMany, belongsTo, morphTo |
| Model events | Lifecycle hooks | Medium | beforeSave, afterCreate, etc. |
| Query builder | Flexible queries | Medium | Type-safe query construction |
| Soft deletes | Recoverable data | Low | Trash/restore pattern |

**WinterCMS Reference:** Storm library, model traits (SoftDelete, Nullable, etc.).

### CLI Tools

| Feature | Why Expected | Complexity | Notes |
|---------|--------------|------------|-------|
| Project scaffolding | Quick start | Medium | `summer:up`, `summer:down` equivalent |
| Plugin creation | Developer productivity | Medium | `create:plugin`, `create:model` |
| Migration commands | Database management | Low | Run, rollback, status |
| Cache commands | Maintenance | Low | Clear, warm caches |

**WinterCMS Reference:** Artisan commands via Laravel foundation.

---

## Differentiators (Competitive Advantage)

Features that set SummerCMS apart. Not expected, but highly valued.

### Performance & Scalability

| Feature | Value Proposition | Complexity | Notes |
|---------|-------------------|------------|-------|
| JVM performance | 10-100x faster than PHP | - | Inherent Scala advantage |
| Compile-time safety | Fewer runtime errors | - | Type system catches bugs |
| Native async | Non-blocking I/O | Medium | Scala Futures, ZIO, Cats Effect |
| Efficient caching | Sub-millisecond responses | High | Edge caching, smart invalidation |

**Rationale:** PHP CMSs (WinterCMS, WordPress) are slow. Scala on JVM with proper architecture delivers enterprise-grade performance.

### Modern Frontend Integration

| Feature | Value Proposition | Complexity | Notes |
|---------|-------------------|------------|-------|
| HTMX native support | No-JS interactivity | Medium | Server-driven UI updates |
| Vue.js integration | Rich client components | Medium | When HTMX isn't enough |
| SSR + hydration | Best of both worlds | High | Server render + client enhance |
| Live Preview | Real-time editing preview | High | See changes before publish |

**Rationale:** HTMX + Vue provides flexibility without JavaScript fatigue. Most interactions via HTMX (fast, simple), Vue for complex widgets.

### API-First Architecture

| Feature | Value Proposition | Complexity | Notes |
|---------|-------------------|------------|-------|
| REST API built-in | Headless capability | Medium | First-class API alongside traditional |
| GraphQL option | Flexible queries | High | Optional, for complex clients |
| API documentation | Developer experience | Low | Auto-generated OpenAPI |
| Versioned APIs | Stability | Medium | v1, v2 without breaking clients |

**Rationale:** Headless is the 2025 trend. SummerCMS should work as traditional CMS AND headless backend.

### Type-Safe Plugin Development

| Feature | Value Proposition | Complexity | Notes |
|---------|-------------------|------------|-------|
| Scala plugin API | Compile-time checks | High | Plugin interfaces with types |
| IDE autocomplete | Developer productivity | - | Free with typed API |
| Plugin testing framework | Quality assurance | Medium | Built-in test utilities |
| Hot reload | Development speed | High | Detect plugin changes |

**Rationale:** PHP plugins fail at runtime with cryptic errors. Scala catches issues at compile time.

### Advanced Workflow

| Feature | Value Proposition | Complexity | Notes |
|---------|-------------------|------------|-------|
| Multi-stage approval | Enterprise workflows | High | Draft -> Review -> Approve -> Publish |
| Content scheduling | Marketing campaigns | Medium | Time-based publish/unpublish |
| Audit logging | Compliance | Medium | Who changed what, when |
| Role-based workflows | Flexible processes | High | Different flows per content type |

**WinterCMS Reference:** Apparatus scenario system provides workflow patterns.

### Multisite & Multi-tenant

| Feature | Value Proposition | Complexity | Notes |
|---------|-------------------|------------|-------|
| Multiple sites | One install, many sites | High | Shared core, separate content |
| Site cloning | Rapid deployment | Medium | Copy site structure |
| Per-site themes | Design flexibility | Medium | Different look per site |
| Shared content | Reuse across sites | High | Global assets/content |

**WinterCMS Reference:** Golem15.SiteManager plugin.

### AI Integration (2025+ trend)

| Feature | Value Proposition | Complexity | Notes |
|---------|-------------------|------------|-------|
| AI content assist | Writing help | Medium | Integration points for LLMs |
| Auto-translation | Multilingual content | Medium | AI-powered i18n |
| Smart tagging | Auto-categorization | Medium | AI metadata generation |
| Content recommendations | Engagement | High | Related content suggestions |

**WinterCMS Reference:** Golem15.AI plugin with OpenAI/Perplexity integration.

---

## Anti-Features (Do NOT Build)

Features other CMFs do that are problematic. Deliberately avoid.

| Anti-Feature | Why Avoid | What to Do Instead |
|--------------|-----------|-------------------|
| Kitchen-sink core | Bloated, slow, hard to maintain | Minimal core + plugin ecosystem |
| Visual page builders | Complex, fragile, poor performance | Component-based with good defaults |
| Magic string configurations | Runtime errors, no IDE support | Typed configuration with validation |
| Closed marketplace | Vendor lock-in | Open plugin format, community repos |
| WordPress-style "hooks everywhere" | Spaghetti code, unpredictable | Explicit extension points, typed APIs |
| Database-stored code | Security risk, hard to version | Code in filesystem, config in DB |
| Monolithic frontend | Tightly coupled, hard to customize | Decoupled frontend, HTMX by default |
| Real-time collaboration (Phase 1) | Complex, requires WebSocket infra | Defer to Phase 3+, use optimistic locking |
| GraphQL by default | Over-engineering for most sites | REST default, GraphQL as optional plugin |

### Specific Patterns to Avoid

**God Object Plugin Architecture:**
Don't create a single "Plugin" class that handles registration, boot, routing, events, and everything else. Instead, use composition with specific handlers.

**Inner Platform Effect:**
Don't make the YAML configuration so flexible it becomes a programming language. Define clear boundaries for what's configurable vs. what requires code.

**Dead Code Accumulation:**
Establish deprecation policies early. Don't ship deprecated features that linger forever.

---

## Feature Dependencies

Features must be built in order based on dependencies.

```
[Foundation Layer]
Database/ORM ──────────┐
                       ├──► Plugin System ──► Everything Else
User/Auth ────────────┘

[Core CMS Layer]
Plugin System ──► Theme System ──► Frontend Components
      │
      └──► Backend Admin ──► YAML Forms ──► Content Management

[Advanced Layer]
Content Management ──► Versioning ──► Workflow ──► Scheduling
                   │
                   └──► API Layer ──► Headless Mode

[Extension Layer]
All Core ──► Multisite
         │
         ├──► AI Integration
         │
         └──► Real-time Collaboration
```

### Critical Path for MVP

1. **Database/ORM** - Everything depends on data persistence
2. **User/Auth** - Backend requires authentication
3. **Plugin System** - All features are plugins
4. **Backend Admin** - Content management UI
5. **YAML Forms** - Backend forms for content
6. **Theme System** - Frontend rendering
7. **Content Management** - Pages, posts, media

---

## Complexity Assessment

Rough complexity for major features (effort in developer-weeks, assuming senior developer).

| Feature Category | Complexity | Estimated Effort | Risk |
|------------------|------------|------------------|------|
| Database/ORM Layer | High | 8-12 weeks | Medium (Scala ecosystem mature) |
| Plugin System | Very High | 12-16 weeks | High (architectural decisions) |
| Backend Admin UI | High | 10-14 weeks | Medium (Vue.js, established patterns) |
| YAML Form Engine | High | 8-12 weeks | Medium (complex parsing + rendering) |
| Theme/Template System | Medium | 6-8 weeks | Low (Scala templates exist) |
| User/Auth System | Medium | 4-6 weeks | Low (standard patterns) |
| Content Management | Medium | 6-8 weeks | Low (straightforward CRUD) |
| Media Library | High | 8-10 weeks | Medium (file handling, transforms) |
| CLI Tools | Low | 2-4 weeks | Low (standard tooling) |
| API Layer (REST) | Medium | 4-6 weeks | Low (well-understood) |
| Multisite | Very High | 12-16 weeks | High (data isolation complex) |
| Workflow Engine | High | 8-12 weeks | Medium (state machines) |

### Total MVP Estimate

Core MVP (Plugin + Admin + Theme + Content): **40-60 weeks** of development effort.

---

## WinterCMS Feature Mapping

Key WinterCMS features and their SummerCMS equivalents.

### Core Modules

| WinterCMS | SummerCMS Equivalent | Notes |
|-----------|----------------------|-------|
| System module | `summer-core` | Plugin management, updates, settings |
| Backend module | `summer-admin` | Admin panel, controllers, forms |
| CMS module | `summer-cms` | Themes, pages, components |
| Storm library | `summer-orm` | Database abstraction layer |

### Golem15 Plugins to Replicate

| Plugin | Priority | Complexity | Notes |
|--------|----------|------------|-------|
| **Apparatus** | P0 - Critical | Very High | Core DI, scenarios, backend utilities |
| **User** | P0 - Critical | Medium | Auth, JWT, GDPR |
| **Blog** | P1 - High | Medium | Content example, commonly needed |
| **PaymentGateway** | P2 - Medium | Very High | Complex FSM, financial logic |
| **Translate** | P1 - High | High | i18n infrastructure |
| **Menu** | P1 - High | Low | Navigation builder |
| **SEO** | P1 - High | Medium | Meta tags, sitemap |
| **Sitemap** | P1 - High | Low | XML sitemap generation |
| **SiteManager** | P2 - Medium | High | Multisite functionality |
| **AI** | P3 - Low | Medium | AI integration patterns |
| **WebSockets** | P3 - Low | High | Real-time features |
| **Chat** | P3 - Low | High | Real-time messaging |
| **FAQ** | P2 - Medium | Low | Simple content type |
| **Quote** | P2 - Medium | Medium | Business logic example |

### Architectural Patterns to Preserve

| WinterCMS Pattern | SummerCMS Approach |
|-------------------|-------------------|
| `$require` plugin dependencies | Manifest-declared dependencies |
| `fields.yaml` / `columns.yaml` | YAML/HOCON config files |
| Component `defineProperties()` | Typed property definitions |
| Model `$rules`, `$belongsTo`, etc. | Case class with validation, relations |
| Event system (`Event::fire()`) | Typed event bus, pub/sub |
| Backend behaviors (FormController, ListController) | Traits/mixins for controllers |
| Twig templating | Scala templates or Thymeleaf |
| AJAX Framework (Snowboard) | HTMX native, Vue for complex UI |

### Key Apparatus Framework Concepts

| Concept | Description | SummerCMS Equivalent |
|---------|-------------|----------------------|
| Scenario System | Event-driven workflow engine | Typed FSM with Akka or ZIO |
| Dependency Injection | Auto-wiring components | Scala DI (MacWire, ZIO) |
| Route Resolver | Custom route handling | Type-safe routing (http4s, Play) |
| Backend Injector | CSS/JS injection | Asset pipeline with manifests |
| Form Widgets | Custom form inputs | Widget component system |

---

## Sources

### Primary (HIGH confidence)
- WinterCMS Official Documentation: https://wintercms.com/docs
- WinterCMS Features: https://wintercms.com/features
- October CMS Forms Documentation: https://docs.octobercms.com/3.x/backend/forms.html
- Golem15 WinterCMS Starter CLAUDE.md (local reference)

### Secondary (MEDIUM confidence)
- Craft CMS Features: https://craftcms.com/features
- Statamic Documentation: https://statamic.com/
- Strapi CMS Blog: https://strapi.io/blog/best-cms-2025
- Payload CMS Documentation: https://payloadcms.com/docs

### Market Research (MEDIUM confidence)
- CMS Feature Comparisons (2025): Multiple web search results
- Headless CMS landscape: https://jamstack.org/headless-cms/
- Plugin architecture patterns: https://www.dotcms.com/blog/plugin-achitecture

### Community (LOW confidence, patterns observed)
- WinterCMS GitHub Discussions
- Hacker News threads on CMS architecture
- Various CMS comparison articles (2025)

---

## Gaps and Open Questions

1. **Scala CMS precedent?** No major Scala-based CMS exists. Research Scala web frameworks (Play, http4s, ZIO HTTP) for patterns.

2. **Template engine choice?** Twig is PHP-specific. Options: Twirl (Play), Thymeleaf, Scalate. Needs deeper research.

3. **Hot reload in Scala?** JVM startup is slow. Investigate JRebel, Bloop, or compile daemon for development experience.

4. **YAML parsing performance?** Scala YAML libraries need benchmarking for large config files.

5. **Plugin isolation?** How to safely load third-party plugins without security risks. Classloader isolation? Sandboxing?

These gaps should be addressed during phase-specific research.
