summercms/.planning/phases/01-framework-kernel-foundation/01-VALIDATION.md

phase, slug, status, nyquist_compliant, wave_0_complete, created

phase	slug	status	nyquist_compliant	wave_0_complete	created
01	framework-kernel-foundation	passing	true	true	2026-09-16

Phase 1 — Validation Strategy

Test Infrastructure

Property	Value
Framework	go test (Go 1.27.0)
Config file	No test harness yet; first implementation slice adds Go tests
Quick run	go vet ./... && go test ./... from repo root, then from examples/hello once created
Full suite	Framework, hello app and three hello plugin modules: go vet ./..., go test ./..., go test -race ./...; generated binary integration
Estimated runtime	Measure after dependencies are cached; no assumed threshold

Sampling Rate

• After each implementation task commit, run root go vet ./... && go test ./...; run the same from examples/hello after it exists.
• After each plan wave, run both module checks plus the relevant built-binary smoke.
• Before verify-work, run race tests in all five modules and an end-to-end summer build/hello invocation.
• Record actual feedback latency and single-plugin rebuild latency; no fixed performance promise has been set.

Per-Requirement Verification Map

Requirement	Test type	Automated command or assertion	Initial status
KERN-01	unit + integration	Config precedence and typed decode tests; hello binary prints env-overlay value	Passed
KERN-02	unit + integration	Reordered Register/Boot trace, missing dependency, cycle and duplicate tests	Passed
KERN-03	compile + unit	Hello plugins satisfy optional interfaces; type-assertion discovery	Passed
KERN-04	integration	Stable codegen, plugin:add, go.work, built hello app boot	Passed
KERN-05	unit	Absent optional plugin returns false; present service lookup returns typed value	Passed
KERN-06	unit + race	Three dispatch modes, priority, stable ties, errors and panic recovery	Passed
KERN-07	unit + race	Two app contexts remain isolated; request values passed only via context.Context	Passed
KERN-08	unit	Interface service publish and typed lookup (value, ok)	Passed
KERN-09	integration	Temp app source edit triggers one debounced rebuild and restart, latency line captured	Passed
CLI-01	unit + integration	Plugin command discovery, injected output, non-TTY spinner/progress/table/prompt behavior	Passed

Per-Task Verification Map

Task ID	Plan	Wave	Requirements	Automated check	Status
01-01-01	01	1	KERN-01/02/03/04, CLI-01	Root and hello go vet ./... + go test ./...	Passed
01-01-02	01	1	KERN-04, CLI-01	Same checks plus summer build and built hello command	Passed
01-02-01	02	2	KERN-01/03	go test ./compass ./pact; hello tests	Passed
01-02-02	02	2	KERN-02/03/05/08	go test ./party ./backpack ./pact; hello tests	Passed
01-02-03	02	2	KERN-06/07	go test ./festival ./towel ./backpack; hello tests	Passed
01-03-01	03	3	KERN-04	go test ./internal/build ./cmd/summer; hello tests	Passed
01-03-02	03	3	CLI-01	go test ./bonfire ./cmd/summer; hello tests	Passed
01-03-03	03	3	KERN-09	go test ./internal/dev ./internal/build ./cmd/summer; hello tests	Passed
01-04-01	04	4	KERN-01/02/03/05/06/07/08	go test -race ./compass ./party ./backpack ./festival ./towel ./pact	Passed
01-04-02	04	4	KERN-04/09, CLI-01	bash scripts/check-phase1.sh	Passed

Wave 0 Requirements

• First implementation slice creates examples/hello, its go.mod, and a root go.work that names every example module.
• First implementation slice adds smoke tests for generated app boot and the initial plugin command.
• Final plan expands unit coverage; it does not substitute for executable checks during earlier work.

Manual-Only Verifications

Behavior	Requirement	Why manual	Instructions
Interactive terminal rendering	CLI-01	Terminal appearance varies by terminal emulator	Run hello command in a TTY; inspect spinner/progress/table and prompts. Automated non-TTY assertions remain required.
Rebuild feel	KERN-09	Human experience complements measured latency	Edit one hello plugin file under summer dev; observe restart and printed elapsed time.

Validation Sign-Off

• Every plan task has an automated verification or an explicit Wave 0 dependency.
• No three consecutive implementation tasks lack automated feedback.
• Root, hello app and three plugin modules run go vet, tests and race tests.
• No watch-mode flags in CI commands.
• Set nyquist_compliant: true after all mapped checks exist and pass.

Approval: bash scripts/check-phase1.sh passed 2026-09-16 (root, hello app, base, greeter, optional; built ./bin/hello greeter:hello). Manual TTY rendering remains optional.