CodeRabbit surfaced one outstanding inline finding plus an outside-diff
finding and a finer point on two already-remediated sites; all addressed:
1. (inline, Minor) runtime-slash.cjs:31 — a degenerate input like `/gsd:`,
`gsd:`, or `gsd-` normalizes to empty and the previous fallback returned
the original colon-form input, reintroducing the deprecated shape the
module exists to suppress. Now returns `''` (empty string) so callers
see "no command" instead of an unroutable string. Also catches
whitespace-only inputs the same way. New unit tests pin the contract.
2. (inline, Major) drift.cjs library purity — the earlier remediation
passed `projectDir` into `detectDrift` and re-resolved runtime inside the
library. CodeRabbit (correctly) flagged this as breaking the module's
pure-library contract. detectDrift now accepts `input.runtime` directly;
verify.cmdVerifyCodebaseDrift resolves the runtime once and passes the
literal name in. drift.cjs no longer reads env or config at all.
3. (duplicate inline, Minor) gsd2-import.cjs:475 — when
`gsd2-import --path <dir>` targets a project that isn't the process
cwd, the preview command was formatted for the wrong runtime.
buildPreview now receives the resolved `projectDir` (the same one
used to find the .gsd/ root) instead of the raw `cwd`.
4. (outside-diff, Minor) tests/copilot-install.test.cjs:1-5 — the
`allow-test-rule: integration-test-input` rationale block specifically
named verify.cjs as the fixture, but #3584 changed that test to use a
synthetic input. Comment now describes the real shape of the file's
readFileSync usage (commands/, agents/, install.js source inputs to
the installer/converter functions under test) and notes the synthetic
substitution for the bin/lib path.
Full suite: 9366/9366 pass (+1 new test). Lint clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Codex review surfaced five issues in the initial slash-formatter PR — three MED
and two LOW. All five are addressed:
1. (MED) formatter corrupted argument tails under codex runtime. Splitting on
the first whitespace and lowercasing only the command token preserves
path-like arguments (`Map-Codebase --paths C:\\Users\\Me\\Project`) and
case-sensitive flag values. (`runtime-slash.cjs`)
2. (MED) profile-output `cmdGenerateDevPreferences` emitted a hardcoded
`command_name: '/gsd-dev-preferences'`. Replaced with
`formatGsdSlash('dev-preferences', resolveRuntime(cwd))` so the structured
result honors codex/skills runtime distinction. (`profile-output.cjs`)
3. (MED) `drift.detectDrift` → `buildMessage` called `resolveRuntime(null)`,
ignoring a project's `.planning/config.json` `runtime` setting when
`GSD_RUNTIME` env var was absent. Threaded `projectDir` through
`detectDrift({projectDir})` → `buildMessage(..., projectDir)` →
`resolveRuntime(projectDir)`. `verify.cmdVerifyCodebaseDrift` now passes
`cwd` into the detect call. (`drift.cjs`, `verify.cjs`)
4. (LOW) `gsd2-import.buildPreview` had the same env-vs-config issue. Threaded
`cwd` through `buildPreview(..., projectDir)` for parity. (`gsd2-import.cjs`)
5. (LOW) The codex emitter test only asserted absence of `/gsd:` — a regression
to `/gsd-` (skills) form in codex output would have passed undetected.
Added positive assertions that every gsd-referencing fix string under
`GSD_RUNTIME=codex` contains `$gsd-` and contains neither `/gsd-` nor
`/gsd:`. Also added formatter unit tests pinning the argument-tail
preservation contract for both hyphen and codex runtimes.
Full suite: 9365/9365 pass (+2 new). Lint clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Introduce `runtime-slash.cjs` as the single source of truth for emitting
GSD slash-command references in user-facing runtime output and persisted
artifacts. `formatGsdSlash(commandName, runtime)` produces `/gsd-<cmd>`
for skills-based runtimes (Claude/Cursor/OpenCode/Kilo/etc.) and
`$gsd-<cmd>` for Codex. The deprecated `/gsd:<cmd>` colon form is never
emitted — pasting a recommended-action command into Claude Code now
routes correctly instead of failing with `Unknown command`.
Wired into the high-impact emitters identified in #3584:
- `init.cjs` `cmdInitManager` recommended_actions[].command (the
original failure path in the bug report) plus the no-ROADMAP /
no-STATE error hints.
- `phase.cjs` `cmdPhaseAdd`, `cmdPhaseAddBatch`, `cmdPhaseInsert` —
ROADMAP.md `Plans:` references now persist the routable form
instead of the legacy colon form.
- `verify.cjs` `cmdValidateHealth` — every fix-hint addIssue() call
(E001/E002/E003/E004/E005, W002/W003/W008/W009/W011/W016/W018) and
the persisted STATE.md regenerate / MILESTONES.md backfill notes.
- `milestone.cjs` `cmdMilestoneComplete` — Operator Next Steps tail
rewrite.
- `validate-command-router.cjs` — `validate context` recommendation
strings for WARNING/CRITICAL utilization bands.
- `workstream.cjs` — missing .planning hint.
- `profile-output.cjs` — `generate-claude-md` workflow enforcement
block, project/skills fallbacks, profile placeholder, and the
dev-preferences refresh hints.
- `drift.cjs`, `gsd2-import.cjs`, `commands.cjs scaffold context` —
remaining one-off persisted references.
Runtime detection: `resolveRuntime(projectDir)` reads
`process.env.GSD_RUNTIME` first, then a side-effect-free direct read of
`.planning/config.json` (NOT `loadConfig`, which would normalize legacy
keys and re-write the file just to read the runtime name).
Tests:
- `tests/bug-3584-runtime-slash-formatter.test.cjs` — 22 unit tests
covering the pure formatter and resolver (hyphen vs codex, prefix
normalization, defensive returns, env/config/default chain).
- `tests/bug-3584-runtime-slash-emitters.test.cjs` — 6 integration
tests exercising `init manager`, `phase add` (via the structured
`roadmap get-phase` payload to avoid raw-text matching on the
on-disk artifact), `validate health`, `validate context`, and the
codex variant.
- Existing tests updated to assert the new contract: validate-context
recommendations, claude-md workflow block, milestone complete
Operator Next Steps. Copilot-install engine-conversion test now
asserts against a synthetic input since bin/lib/*.cjs no longer
contains literal `/gsd:` references for the install-time converter
to rewrite.
INVENTORY.md and INVENTORY-MANIFEST.json updated for the new module
(64 CLI modules shipped, +1).
Fixes#3584
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
