Fold Copilot's residual runtime-literal branches onto descriptor-driven
hostBehaviors. Several issue premises were inaccurate (verified via research)
and deliberately NOT followed: writesSharedSettings/"legacy exclusion list"
(per-runtime descriptor data, copilot's false is correct); RUNTIME_CONTENT_DISPATCH.copilot
+ installSurface==='copilot-instructions' (already descriptor-driven);
extendedHookEvents (closed Claude/Gemini enum — hooks extended in code instead);
reapply ternary (already folded, kimi #2095).
Real folds (all byte-parity — golden byte-identical for every runtime):
- src/install-engine.cts + src/surface.cts: the two `.agent.md` filename cutovers
(_copyStaged + _syncGsdDir) unified onto hostBehaviors.agentFileExtension via a
new exported agentFileExtensionFor() accessor (kills the two-mechanism divergence).
- src/runtime-artifact-conversion.cts: applyAgentPathRewrites' copilot skip →
hostBehaviors.noPathRewrite:true (antigravity #2096 precedent).
- bin/install.js uninstall: the two isCopilot cleanup branches → installSurface===
'copilot-instructions' gate (symmetric with install-time).
- bin/install.js: `!isCopilot` in the two skipSharedHooksInstall checks →
hostBehaviors.skipSharedHooksInstall:true (copilot has no shared gsd-*.js hooks).
- bin/install.js: three dead legacy inline-agent-loop isCopilot refs removed
(copilot ∈ _DESCRIPTOR_AGENTS_RUNTIMES → unreachable; byte-parity proven by clean
golden + real reachable-runtime install diffs). isCopilot dropped from 4 destructures.
Zero live `runtime==='copilot'`/`isCopilot` branches remain in bin/install.js,
install-engine.cts, surface.cts, or runtime-artifact-conversion.cts (AC2 guard scans all four).
UPGRADE 1 (multi-event hook bus): buildCopilotHookConfig() now emits preToolUse/
postToolUse/userPromptSubmitted/sessionEnd advisory handlers alongside sessionStart
(static inline bash/powershell — deterministic, golden-trackable). Only copilot.json's
gsd-session.json hash changes.
UPGRADE 2 (background dispatch): surfaced via the negotiated contract only —
dispatch.background:true exceeds the declarative-cli baseline and survives negotiation
with no downgrade warning. NO .agent.md frontmatter field (copilot has none). MCP
companion out of scope (AC4 names only 2 upgrades).
Tests: declarative-reference-copilot (adapter/axes/fail-closed + AC2 4-file source-grep
guard) + copilot-upgrades (live 5-event hook wiring; dispatch.background negotiation).
Matrix EoS note + how-to; changeset (Changed). capability-registry regenerated.
Incidental flaky-test RE-ARCHITECTURE (no-defer, maintainer-directed):
tests/opencode-review-reconstruction.property.test.cjs spawned ~600 synchronous
execFileSync('jq') subprocesses (numRuns:200 × 3 fast-check properties, one jq per
generated stream); a single jq freezing on a contended macos-22 CI runner hung the whole
unit-test chunk to its 600s kill (this PR's CI). --test-force-exit can't interrupt a
synchronous execFileSync, so the cure is to stop spawning per case, not just time-bound
it. Re-architected to run the SHIPPED jq program over the whole fast-check corpus in ONE
jq process: each generated stream is one compact-JSON array per line in a temp file,
`jq -c <PROGRAM>` (no -s) applies PROGRAM to each array (`.` == the array, exactly what
production's `jq -rs <file>` sees after slurping) and emits one result per line —
empirically byte-identical to the per-stream form across embedded-newline/empty/quote/
unicode/null-drop cases, and file-input (like production) so there's no stdin pipe to
deadlock on large I/O. ~600 spawns → 6; coverage unchanged (200-case corpus per property,
deterministic seeds) plus explicit boundary/diagnostic example batches. Still property-
tests the real shipped jq (no JS reimplementation). Per-call jq timeout retained as a
belt-and-suspenders bound.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Records the statusline scope boundary decided during triage of #2160-2164:
the statusline sources only local, read-only data (refine-existing + new-local),
never credentials or external/network APIs. #2164 (account-usage segment) is
out of scope on this boundary; #2163 (git) is in-scope but on the feature track;
#2160/2161/2162 are approved enhancements.
- docs/adr/2164-statusline-scope-boundary.md (new ADR, Accepted)
- docs/adr/README.md (index row)
- CONTEXT.md (### Statusline glossary/seam entry)
- .out-of-scope/statusline-account-usage.md (#2164 rejection record)
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Fold CodeBuddy's residual runtime-literal branches onto descriptor-driven
hostBehaviors (the issue's "zero branches remain" premise was inaccurate — 2
lived):
- Folded the `if (isCodebuddy)` commands/ report duplicate (byte-identical to
the generic reportCommandsDir block above it) onto
hostBehaviors.reportCommandsDir:true, matching cursor's #2089 precedent.
- Deleted the dead `else if (isCodebuddy)` agent-conversion arm (codebuddy ∈
_DESCRIPTOR_AGENTS_RUNTIMES → gated out before the legacy chain, same dead-arm
pattern removed for augment/trae in #2097).
- Removed isCodebuddy from all 4 destructure sites (now comments only, mirroring
the #2096 isAntigravity fold). Zero live isCodebuddy reads remain.
UPGRADE 1 (extended hook bus): populate extendedHookEvents with the full
extended set SubagentStop/Stop/PreCompact/SubagentStart (qwen #2092 / kimi
precedent — codebuddy previously had extendedHookEvents:[] so it got NONE of
these). The generic applySettingsJsonHooks loop wires them, so CodeBuddy's
settings.json now gains all four subagent-lifecycle + stop/compact hooks it
previously lacked, matching Qwen/Kimi coverage. No source change (the
HOOK_EVENT_SURFACES SDK catalog is a locked dict; all 4 events are already in
the validator enum; hookEvents already 'claude'). settings.json is golden-
excluded → no golden change.
UPGRADE 2 (background dispatch): surfaced via the negotiated capability contract
only. CodeBuddy's dispatch.background:true legitimately exceeds the declarative-
cli baseline (false) and survives negotiation with no warning. NO agent-file
frontmatter field is emitted: the CodeBuddy CLI (GSD's install target,
~/.codebuddy/agents/) has NO background-dispatch frontmatter field — background
is a caller-side run_in_background invocation param (verified against
codebuddy.ai/docs/cli/sub-agents); the issue's agentMode/enabledAutoRun are
IDE-only (codebuddy.cn, a different product). Emitting them would be a non-
functional false-green, so it is deliberately not done.
Golden: byte-identical for all 16 runtimes (folds are console/failures-report
only; UPGRADE 1 → golden-excluded settings.json; UPGRADE 2 → no artifact
change). Tests: declarative-reference-codebuddy (adapter/axes/fail-closed
negotiation + AC2 source-grep guard) + codebuddy-upgrades (live install asserts
all 4 extended hooks wired; dispatch.background survives negotiation above
baseline). Matrix + install-on-your-runtime updated; changeset (Changed).
capability-registry regenerated.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Fold augment's runtime-literal conversion branches onto descriptor-driven
hostBehaviors and delete dead code:
- Site A (_applyRuntimeRewrites case 'augment'): the 4 ~/.augment dot-dir
regexes now derive from getDirName('augment') via escapeRegExp (byte-
identical; getDirName('augment')==='.augment') — no runtime literal.
- Site B (applyRuntimeContentRewritesForCommandsInPlace): the
`if (runtime==='augment')` markdown-converter branch now reads
runtime.hostBehaviors.commandBodyConverter and dispatches through a local
COMMAND_BODY_CONVERTERS map (degrade-closed on unknown/absent name).
- Deleted dead `claudeToAugmentTools` map (zero refs; orphaned by ADR-1508
single-sourcing) and the unreachable `else if (isAugment)` agent-conversion
branch (augment ∈ _DESCRIPTOR_AGENTS_RUNTIMES → gated out upstream).
- Incidental orphan cleanup (no-defer): removed the equally-unreachable
`else if (isTrae)` agent-conversion arm left behind by trae's already-merged
migration #2094 (trae ∈ _DESCRIPTOR_AGENTS_RUNTIMES, same upstream gate).
copilot/windsurf/codebuddy arms are removed by their own pending migrations.
UPGRADE 3 (transport:mcp): register the GSD companion MCP server in Augment's
settings.json under mcpServers.gsd (Augment hosts MCP in settings.json, not a
standalone file). mergeGsdMcpServerIntoSettings mutates the in-memory settings
object finishInstall already writes (gated on hostBehaviors.mcpCompanion===
'settings-json'); non-destructive + idempotent; symmetric uninstall removal.
settings.json is golden-excluded, so no golden change. UPGRADE 1 (named/
background dispatch) + UPGRADE 2 (settings-json hook bus, Claude dialect)
were already live in production — this adds tests exercising both.
Golden: byte-identical for all 16 runtimes (folds preserve regex behavior;
MCP lives in golden-excluded settings.json) — verified by a real double-install
tree diff. Tests: declarative-reference-augment (adapter/axes/fail-closed/
undocumented-sub-axes + source-grep guard scoped to conversion-logic branches)
+ augment-upgrades (dispatch negotiation, hook-bus live install, MCP add/
idempotent/preserve/uninstall). Matrix + connect-gsd-mcp-server + a stale
install-on-your-runtime hook-ownership claim corrected; changeset (Changed).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Fold all runtime==='kimi'/isKimi logic branches into descriptor-driven
hostBehaviors (localInstallDeferred, verificationStyle, agentManifestStyle,
reapplyCommand, doneBannerStyle) + add 'kimi' to _DESCRIPTOR_AGENTS_RUNTIMES.
Kimi's skills/kimi-agents dispatch was already descriptor-driven (converter-by-
name + kimi-agents kind). Zero isKimi/runtime==='kimi' branches remain.
UPGRADE 1 (native hook bus): new hooksSurface 'kimi-hooks-toml' + a marker-
delimited config.toml [[hooks]] emitter (buildKimiHooksTomlBlock/writeKimiHooksToml
in runtime-hooks-surface.cts; resolveKimiHooksTomlDir in runtime-homes.cts).
GSD's lifecycle hooks now wire into Kimi's native ~/.kimi/config.toml (Context7-
confirmed path) at SessionStart/PreToolUse/Stop/PreCompact/SubagentStart/
SubagentStop — kimi becomes a hooks/ consumer (the 3 && !isKimi exclusion guards
removed). config.toml holds absolute install paths so it's golden-excluded via
an exact relative-path (.kimi/config.toml), not a basename (which would blind
Codex's config.toml). New hooksSurface value added to the closed enum in
capability-validator + runtime-config-adapter-registry.
UPGRADE 2 (background dispatch): flip dispatch.backgroundDispatch true (Kimi's
Agent tool takes run_in_background; root agent already gets the Agent tool), so
negotiation no longer flattens dispatch. subagentToolkit stays 'undocumented'
per AC (coder/explore/plan have distinct tool policies).
MCP transport explicitly deferred (no installer-driven MCP for any runtime).
Golden: only kimi.json changes (hooks/ scripts now installed); all 15 others +
claude-local byte-identical (kilo/zcode keep their own exclusions). Tests:
kimi-imperative-reference (adapter/axes/fail-closed/hostBehaviors + source-grep
guard) + kimi-upgrades (config.toml [[hooks]] SessionStart + marker idempotency
+ backgroundDispatch negotiation). CONTEXT.md glossary + matrix + how-to updated;
changeset (Added).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Fold trae logic branches into descriptor-driven reads: skipSharedHooksInstall
gates (dropped && !isTrae), and the case 'trae' path-rewrite arm now computes
the self-alias from the descriptor-driven dirName (.trae). Dead isTrae bindings
removed from uninstall/writeManifest/finishInstall. trae's skills dispatch was
already descriptor-driven (converter-by-name). RUNTIME_CONTENT_DISPATCH.trae is
left as a runtime-keyed table registration (its regex/callback rewrites can't be
a byte-identical descriptor map — matches cursor/windsurf/cline). trae stays in
RUNTIME_FLAG_IDS: isTrae still gates the agents-converter selection (agents out
of scope; removal gated on the cross-runtime agents-dispatch migration).
Byte-identical golden parity for all 16 runtimes.
UPGRADE: SOLO stage/trigger metadata — emitted Trae SKILL.md now carries
stage: workflow (descriptor-gated via hostBehaviors.soloStageMetadata) so
Trae's SOLO Agent can auto-invoke GSD skills at the corresponding stage. Field
shape is best-effort/inferred (Trae publishes no formal schema). trae.json
golden regenerated.
Tests: trae-imperative-reference (adapter/axes/fail-closed shouldFlattenDispatch
+ no runtime==='trae' source-grep, isTrae exempted for agents) + trae-upgrades
(stage: workflow on installed SKILL.md, descriptor-gated). Matrix note +
changeset added.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Fold remaining isKilo logic branches into descriptor-driven reads:
finishPermissionWriter (uninstall cleanup), skipSharedHooksInstall (hooks
copy), and a skills converter-name registry (the artifactLayout.converter
field is now load-bearing, not decorative). frontmatterDialect stays the
documented dispatch key for frontmatter (no descriptor field for it). Dead
isKilo destructure bindings removed. Byte-identical golden parity for all 16
runtimes (opencode, which shares kilo's combined-family path, verified clean).
UPGRADE 1 (hook bus): install .kilo/plugins/gsd-core.js native plugin +
extensionEvents:"kilo" + EXTENSION_EVENT_SURFACES.kilo (OpenCode-fork bus).
UPGRADE 2 (active model): populate runtimeTierDefaults.kilo + thread
modelOverride through convertClaudeToKiloFrontmatter — model no longer stripped
from agents. UPGRADE 3 (MCP): document the gsd-core MCP companion under kilo's
mcp config key. UPGRADE 4 (named dispatch): agents/*.md mode:subagent roster is
the Task-tool dispatch surface (tested); subagentToolkit stays 'undocumented'
per AC so dispatch degrades to 'degraded' by design.
Model-catalog single-source edit ripples the shared model-catalog.json hash
into all 16 golden fixtures (expected). Inline defect fixes (no-defer): stale-
bake-guard resolveAgentDir 'agent'->'agents' (was a silent no-op for opencode/
codex), hardcoded 'Removed OpenCode plugin' uninstall log -> generic, and the
connect-gsd-mcp-server.md OpenCode mcpServers->mcp doc error.
Tests: kilo-imperative-reference (adapter/axes/fail-closed/degradation/
hostBehaviors + widened isKilo source-grep across 4 modules) + kilo-upgrades
(plugin parity+load, model-override converter, agents dispatch surface, MCP
doc). Matrix + how-to + config docs updated; changeset added.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
trek-e's re-review asked to either mechanize the Step 9.5 element
extraction or add an inline note justifying why it stays manual, so a
future maintainer doesn't read it as an oversight.
Verified the premise: the requirement-side edge-probe path (spec-phase
Step 5.5) it mirrors is ALSO a hand-populated heredoc + fail-loud
<replace:> placeholder guard — not a mechanical parse. The UI probe
mirrors that idiom verbatim. Mechanizing would be worse: a UI-SPEC has no
single machine-parseable "elements" column (surfaces are spread across the
design-token tables, Copywriting, and researcher-named prose), so a
regex/table parse would fail-OPEN (miss a prose-named surface, or feed a
design-token row as a bogus element).
Expanded the inline comment to state the parity + the fail-open rationale
explicitly. No logic change; regenerated the workflow size baseline and
the 16 golden-install-parity fixtures for the +847 B comment.
Refs #1867
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_017vYn26e3nkDNxcpty1ciPJ
ci-preflight (full test:unit) caught a Phase-1 registration gap: the
tsc-generated gsd-core/bin/lib/ui-consideration-probe.cjs was not in the
eslint.config.mjs global ignore list, failing 551-eslint-bin-lib-coverage
("each bin/lib/*.cjs is linted xor ignored according to migration state",
ADR-457/#537). Generated artifacts are ignored, not linted — added it next to
the sibling probe adapters (edge-probe/probe-core/prohibition-enforcement).
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01BKt4hgNZwXSeJYJtYAQUSS
Ship-safe registration + regenerated snapshots for the #1867 UI-consideration
probe (Phase 3, SHIP-01):
- CONTEXT.md: PROBE.ui.{verification,axis,seam} predicates + ui-consideration
-probe added to PROBE.family (machine-canon for the 3rd adapter, MIXED axis).
- agents/gsd-ui-{researcher,checker}.md: one @-include of
references/ui-consideration-probe.md each (both under the 24576 agent cap).
- docs/INVENTORY.md + INVENTORY-MANIFEST.json: register the reference doc and
the compiled ui-consideration-probe.cjs (inventory-manifest-sync green).
- tests/fixtures/golden-install-parity/*.json (16 runtimes): recaptured against
a clean full build — folds in the deferred Phase-1 (ref doc, plan-phase lift)
and Phase-2 (ui-phase step, UI-SPEC section) install-surface changes.
- tests/agent-size-baseline.json: ratcheted the two grown UI agents.
- .changeset/vivid-orcas-chatter.md: type Added (pr updated at PR-open).
Inventory/golden/size gates green; lint:ci + lint:docs + lint:changeset green.
The plan-phase.md PRE_PHASE6 ceiling stays RED pending #1852 (unchanged).
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01BKt4hgNZwXSeJYJtYAQUSS
Record resolved UI-state considerations in the UI-SPEC, backward-compatibly
(Phase 2, WIRE-02). templates/UI-SPEC.md gains a '## UI Considerations' section
(analog of SPEC '## Edge Coverage') after '## Copywriting Contract' — a
| Category | Element(s) | Status | Resolution / Reason | table with
covered/backstop/unresolved rows in the locked probe-core projectTruths format
the shipped plan-phase lift (plan-phase.md:921) reads. Empty/error COPY stays in
Copywriting; this section covers shape-rooted STATE and references those rows
(de-dup).
Tests: docs-fixtures parsed-heading assertion (UI Considerations present +
distinct from Copywriting Contract; allow-test-rule, parsed structure); typed
backward-compat (projectTruths(undefined/[])===[], old UI-SPEC still plans —
Hyrum), format-match, and idempotency (proposeElements determinism). The
template-structure test was the RED driver.
Install-parity cascade (INVENTORY-MANIFEST + 16 golden fixtures +
agent-size-baseline) deferred to Phase 3 SHIP-01, as planned.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01BKt4hgNZwXSeJYJtYAQUSS
Add the live ui-phase producer path for the UI-consideration probe (Phase 2,
WIRE-01). Two small exports on the Phase-1 adapter — proposeElements (the
propose-then-confirm view of detected kinds + applicable categories) and
autoResolve (the deterministic --auto floor that never dismisses and never
auto-backstops an unclassified item, #1110) — plus a post-verification
'## 9.5 UI-Consideration Probe' step in ui-phase.md mirroring spec-phase 5.5's
RUNTIME_DIR shim + fatal-invoke/malformed-report/zero-applicable fail-closed
guards, propose-then-confirm (the partial-cue recall mitigation), and the
'## UI Considerations' write-back in the shipped plan-phase.md:921 lift format.
autoResolve is the CODE floor; the covered-upgrade stays workflow prose (the
two-layer --auto). Un-upgraded backstops route to insufficient_spec ->
human_needed at verify, never a silent pass (#1154).
Tests: +8 typed (proposeElements shape/determinism, autoResolve never-dismiss,
partial-cue strict-subset) — structured-value only. ui-phase.md size baseline
ratcheted 15477->24447 (under DEFAULT cap). The plan-phase.md PRE_PHASE6 ceiling
stays RED pending #1852 (unchanged from Phase 1).
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01BKt4hgNZwXSeJYJtYAQUSS
Separate *-UI-SPEC.md glob (edge-coverage glob exclusion at :746 left intact
- Hyrum/D-08); a terse lift bullet reusing the ## Edge Coverage rule verbatim
(covered -> truths string, backstop -> flat scalar {statement, verification:
backstop}, unresolved -> assumption; no new verb - ADR-550 #1278/#1154); and a
no-silent-drop checklist line. Lift logic lives ONLY in the plan-phase
workflow, never gsd-planner.md (D-10, agent-size cap).
NOTE: this grows plan-phase.md +862B, over the #1168 PRE_PHASE6 ceiling (94519)
by ~802B, so the workflow-size gates are RED until #1852's lazy-split lands the
-21KB headroom. Deliberately does NOT raise the ceiling constant (would collide
with #1820/#1835's in-flight raise). #1867 sequences after #1852; rebase +
regenerate the size baseline then.
Reference doc mirrors edge-probe.md structure but links rather than re-argues;
states the MIXED-axis boundary (closed compiled shape-rooted subset here; open
UX subset - real-time/offline, a11y depth, i18n/RTL - prose-owned in
domain-probes.md). Docs-parity test pins doc taxonomy ids == code UI_TAXONOMY
ids and asserts disjointness from domain-probes.md topics (ADR-456
runtime-contract exemption, see #1867).
Third probe-core adapter on the UI element/state axis, mirroring edge-probe.
Closed 8-id shape-rooted UI_TAXONOMY + element-cue relevance filter
(UI_CUES -> classifyElement -> applicableCategories); unclassified fail-loud
soft-signal (#1110); fail-closed on invalid authored element kinds. All
lifecycle/merge/validation delegated to probe-core verbatim (no fork). Item
question carried in the shared Item.probe field. LIFT-01 proven at the
probe-core primitive level (projectTruths/dispositionForUnverifiableTruth):
backstop considerations route to insufficient_spec, never a silent pass.
Tests assert typed returns off the built .cjs (no source-grep).
#2056 fixed the foreign-prefix collapse for init plan-phase only.
The identical defect remained in three sibling commands that called
findPhaseInternal/getRoadmapPhaseInternal without the guard:
- cmdInitExecutePhase
- cmdInitVerifyWork
- cmdInitPhaseOp
Extracted the #2056 guard into shared helpers (guardedFindPhase /
guardedGetRoadmapPhase) and routed all four init commands through them.
Deleted the local parsePhasePrefix/isForeignPrefixedPhaseQuery copies in
init.cts — the canonical export from phase-id.cts is now used directly,
eliminating the drift risk flagged by both reviewers.
Added 5 regression tests (3 reject + 2 accept-branch) mirroring the
#2056 plan-phase tests.
Update runtimeTierDefaults.codex and providerPresets.openai in
model-catalog.json to the GPT-5.6 family (gpt-5.6-sol/terra/luna),
advancing from the superseded GPT-5.4/5.5 generation.
Model IDs verified against OpenAI developer API docs:
- gpt-5.6-sol: flagship, /, reasoning xhigh
- gpt-5.6-terra: balanced, .50/, reasoning medium
- gpt-5.6-luna: fast/cheap, /, reasoning medium
Tier mapping is 1:1 (Sol↔flagship, Terra↔balanced, Luna↔fast),
so profile semantics are unchanged — only the underlying IDs advance.
Updates: catalog JSON, test assertions (catalog defaults), docs
(CONFIGURATION.md + zh-CN/pt-BR translations, workflow settings),
and changeset.
Closes#2122
Final convergence review found the shared <tag> seam introduced 3 behavior
regressions; fixed all + locked with tests:
- #557 REGRESSION: stripTaggedBlocks's attribute-tolerance stripped `<details open>`
(the ACTIVE-milestone marker) that the old `<details>`-only regex preserved. The
seam now takes `allowAttributes` (default false) — details/decisions strip is
attr-INTOLERANT (preserves `<details open>`); only `<task type="…">` opts in.
Regression test added to roadmap-parser + markdown-sectionizer suites.
- verify.cts actionZones (negative-grep-echo security scan): reverted to a bounded
to-first-close scan `<action>([\s\S]{0,20000}?)</action>` so a grep-echo trick
can't hide behind an unterminated inner <action> (the seam's stop-at-next-open
would drop it). ReDoS-safe via the cap.
- check-command-router HTML-comment strip: `(?:-->|$)` fallback wiped to EOF
(fail-closed spurious gate block) — replaced with stop-at-next-open so an
unclosed `<!--` leaves downstream tags intact.
- Updated the extractTaggedBlocks nested-tag tests to the new (stop-at-next-open)
behavior: `<x><x>inner</x></x>` -> ['inner'].
All vectors still linear; every fix verified in-process.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A convergence audit showed the `<tag>[\s\S]*?</tag>` lazy-scan ReDoS was pervasive
(a dozen+ bespoke copies across roadmap-parser/check-command-router/verify), each
a distinct quadratic vector on a large document with unclosed tags. Rather than
whack-a-mole, single-source them (maintainer-directed):
- markdown-sectionizer: extractTaggedBlocks now shares one ReDoS-safe
`taggedBlockPattern` (stop-at-next-open, bounded optional attributes) and gains
a `stripTaggedBlocks` companion for block removal.
- roadmap-parser: 3 `<details>` strips -> stripTaggedBlocks (behavior-identical —
no <details> here carries attributes).
- verify: actionZones + both <task> loops + their nested <name>/<files>/gate/req
extractions -> extractTaggedBlocks (behavior byte-equivalent, verified).
- check-command-router: the objective|tasks?|action alternation hardened in place
(distinct multi-tag shape); HTML-comment strip gains a `$` fallback.
Every vector now linear (<3ms on 1.5MB adversarial); real content unchanged
(end-to-end verify/roadmap resolution + task extraction confirmed). The only
remaining `<!--…-->` scan (uat.cts:201) is anchored + non-global — one scan, safe.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A ReDoS-completeness audit surfaced a distinct class beyond the tag/bracket
clause: unbounded `[\s\S]*?` / `[^\]]*` lazy-scans searching for a literal
terminator that may never appear, driven quadratic by REPEATED structures in a
large PLAN.md/ROADMAP.md. Folded all 7 in at maintainer direction:
- files_modified `[^\]]*` -> `[^\]]{0,8000}` (commands.cts, verify.cts): 39.7s -> 0.9s.
- Plans-count `[\s\S]*?` -> section-local `(?:(?!\n#{1,4}\s)[\s\S])*?` — stops at the
next heading (semantically correct: Plans: belongs to the phase's own section)
(roadmap.cts x3, phase.cts): 36s -> 4ms.
- <tag> extraction `([\s\S]*?)` -> stop at the next same-tag opening
`((?:(?!<tag>)[\s\S])*?)` (verify.cts x3, markdown-sectionizer.cts): ~6s -> 2ms.
Every vector is now linear (comprehensively re-measured); real content matches
(end-to-end `roadmap get-phase` still resolves Plans-counted phases). Pre-existing;
byte-behavior preserved for realistic inputs.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Review caught that the prior commit bounded only the paren tag clause and left
the SIBLING bracket-prefix `(?:\[[^\]]+\]\s*)?` (same host regexes, before Phase)
UNBOUNDED — the identical quadratic reachable via a `[...]` run (measured ~16s at
1.7MB). Bound `[^\]]+`/`[^\]]*` -> {1,200}/{0,200} across all 19 phase/milestone
heading prefixes. Comprehensive re-measurement now shows EVERY vector linear
(bracket/paren/id/name/milestone all ~2-44ms at 2.45MB; bracket scaling
2k->2ms, 4k->5ms, 8k->10ms). Also: update the #1729 literal-mirror parity test
off its stale unbounded constant, and add limit-1 (199) boundary coverage.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The canonical OPTIONAL_PHASE_TAG_SOURCE tag clause `(?:\s*\([^)\n]*\))?` (and its
inlined literal mirrors across 11 modules) had an UNBOUNDED body, making the
optional-group + /g header scan quadratic on adversarial ROADMAP.md/STATE.md — a
long run of `(` after a header ran ~18.8s at 1.7MB. Bound the body to {0,200} in
the constant AND every mirror in lockstep (the #1729 "both forms change together"
contract), so the scan is linear: the same 1.7MB input now resolves in ~9ms
(measured), while real tags (a handful of chars) still match and a 201-char tag
is rejected. Added a #2128 boundary regression to the #1729 suite.
Pre-existing (byte-identical before/after the Phase 4 migrations); folded in at
maintainer direction rather than deferred.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Re-review found the `// phase-id-owner:` suppression treated a `//` embedded in a
string literal as a comment — help/doc text quoting the sanction syntax (the exact
string the scanner's own main() prints) would silently suppress a real
re-derivation. Require the marker to LEAD its own comment line (`^\s*//…`), so a
`//` inside a string or trailing a code line never counts. All 5 real sanctions
are already dedicated lines (scanRepo stays green); trailing same-line sanctions
are no longer honored — put the comment on the line directly above.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
