* fix(#1906): require node-test clean-fixture causation control
The node-test fail-first proof accepted a deceptive content-independent
negative test — one that reds merely because GSD_PROHIB_SUBJECT is set,
ignoring the subject's content — whenever no cleanFixture was supplied,
because #1346's causation control was opt-in. The proof's observed signal
(RED) thus diverged from its target (RED caused by content) by default.
Make the causation control mandatory for the node-test kind: a descriptor
that omits cleanFixture is un-provable (fail-closed), never accepted under
the weaker violation-only proof. When a clean fixture is present, fail-first
is proven exactly as before (RED on violation AND non-vacuous GREEN on clean).
The lint-rule kind is unchanged (its subject IS the linted file; no
GSD_PROHIB_SUBJECT indirection).
Breaking (Hyrum): a previously-green node-test prohibition with no clean
fixture now hard-gates — blast radius is zero in-tree (no node-test
prohibition ships today; only the lint-rule local/no-source-grep dogfood).
Supersedes ADR-1606 Decision 4 / ADR-550 #1346 addendum's opt-in.
Closes#1906
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_017vYn26e3nkDNxcpty1ciPJ
* docs(#1906): supersede the #1346 opt-in causation control (mandatory for node-test)
Record the node-test mandatory-causation-control supersede across the
governing surfaces:
- ADR-1606 (the enforcement decision-of-record): addendum + Decision 4
annotated + the "Mandatory causation control — REJECTED" alternative
flipped to accepted (premise no longer holds: zero in-tree node-test
consumers).
- ADR-550: the 2026-06-21 #1346 "Why opt-in, not required" paragraph
marked SUPERSEDED, pointing at ADR-1606.
- spec-phase.md: check_clean_fixture is now REQUIRED for node-test
(was "optional").
- CONTEXT.md: PROHIB.enforce.causation predicate updated.
Regenerated the shipped-artifact cascade from the spec-phase.md edit
(+149 B, well under the 40960 cap): 16 golden-install-parity fixtures
and the workflow size baseline.
Refs #1906
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_017vYn26e3nkDNxcpty1ciPJ
The #1279 node-test machine-proof confirmed a known-bad subject drives the
negative test RED, but could not distinguish a genuine content-violation from a
deceptive test that reds merely because GSD_PROHIB_SUBJECT is set. Add an
optional fifth flat scalar `check_clean_fixture` (-> CheckDescriptor.cleanFixture)
threading a KNOWN-CLEAN control subject through projectProhibitions +
descriptorFromProjection. When present, the prover also runs the check against
the clean subject and requires GREEN, so fail-first is proven only when the check
is RED on the violation AND GREEN on the clean subject (content-dependent).
Opt-in and additive: absent a clean fixture the prover behaves exactly as
post-#1314 (no control, documented residual), preserving the zero-authoring
compose path; the lint-rule kind needs no analog (its subject IS the linted
file, no env indirection). Coverage: RED-first deceptive case, positive,
missing-clean fail-closed, round-trip read-back/emit, fast-check property
extended to the 5th scalar, and an end-to-end COMPOSE capstone (honest vs
deceptive). Docs: ADR-550 dated addendum, prohibition-probe reference,
spec-phase + verify-phase workflows.
Closes#1346
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01GsPRb8zvpcT7Eat6vZw8PX
Delivers option (a) from the #1314 maintainer review: thread a fourth flat
scalar check_violation_fixture through the projection so a prohibition authored
at spec-phase machine-proves fail-first and greens through the deterministic
path alone — zero hand-authoring at verify time.
- src/probe-core.cts: Prohibition gains check_violation_fixture?; projectProhibitions
emits it (both kinds) ONLY for a well-formed descriptor and ONLY when non-empty
(blank/absent -> projects absent -> producer hard-gates, never a partial green).
- src/prohibition-enforcement.cts: descriptorFromProjection reads it back into
violationFixture via the same numeric-coercion-safe scalar() normalizer.
- Tests (RED-first, proven non-vacuous by reverting both src edits): CHK-02(#1346)
projection emit, CHK-08(#1346) read-back, CHK-03(D) example round-trip, the
fast-check round-trip property extended to the 4th scalar (the contract trek-e
blocked #1301 on), and a real-subprocess COMPOSE capstone greening end-to-end
through project -> descriptorFromProjection -> default prover+runner.
- Docs flipped from 'hard-gates until #1346' to 'composes end-to-end': verify-phase.md,
prohibition-probe.md, spec-phase.md authoring, ADR-550 addendum, changeset.
#1346 now tracks only the node-test causation residual.
190 affected-suite tests green; eslint + tsc clean; size baseline regenerated.
Addresses the #1314 maintainer review (trek-e):
- Major 1 (fail-OPEN): defaultProveFailFirst's node-test branch only guarded
`if (!fixture)`. A missing/typo'd/stale violationFixture made GSD_PROHIB_SUBJECT
point at a missing file; an honest negative test threw ENOENT *inside its
callback* (a failing test named distinctly from the file), which
isNonVacuousNodeTestRed accepted as proof -> a green forged from a setup crash.
Now requires fs.existsSync(path.resolve(cwd, fixture)) before spawning, symmetric
with the lint-rule path's file-result guard. Regression test pins it (RED without
the guard); a second test pins cwd-relative fixture resolution.
- Major 2 (misleading prose): the #1278 projection carries no violationFixture, so
the deterministic-locate path always hard-gates (fail-closed) until a
check_violation_fixture scalar is threaded through. verify-phase.md and
prohibition-probe.md no longer read as if the projected path produces greens;
the ADR-550 addendum records both items. Tracked as follow-up #1346.
- Documented residual: existence is necessary but not sufficient (a red caused by
the env being set vs the subject's content); recorded as a constraint, in #1346.
- Nit: stale 'NOT attested fail-first' comment -> 'NOT machine-proven fail-first'.
64 tests pass; eslint + tsc clean; changeset valid.
A violation fixture that crashes the negative test at load emits a file-named
# fail 1 — a crash, not the assertion firing red. Require a failing test named
distinctly from the file (isNonVacuousNodeTestRed), symmetric with the clean-pass
non-vacuity guard and the lint-rule specific-rule-id requirement. Closes the one
soundness asymmetry surfaced by adversarial review (code-review IN-01).
* test(1278): RED-first descriptor parity + fail-closed guards + CHK-07 byte-stability (wave 1)
- CHK-03 (RED): extend PROB-14 parity in prohibition-probe.schema.test.cjs to carry the flat
check_kind/check_target/check_rule scalars through project->write->parseMustHavesBlock; the
non-droppable check_kind-presence assertion is the load-bearing RED trigger (fails because
projectProhibitions strips check_* on the current build).
- CHK-07 (GREEN forward-guard): probe-core.test.cjs pins descriptor-less byte-stability +
dispositionForProhibition fail-closed policy, with a t.todo marker forward-locking plan 01-02.
- CHK-06 (RED): prohibition-enforcement.test.cjs asserts descriptorFromProjection export +
fail-closed on absent/partial/unknown descriptors via the projection adapter (RED until 01-03).
- No src/*.cts or .cjs edits; no new test files; lint-test-file-count clean.
* feat(1278): add optional flat-scalar check descriptor fields to Prohibition interface (wave 2)
- check_kind?/check_target?/check_rule? mirror CheckDescriptor.kind/target/rule (minus caller-attested failFirst, #1279)
- optional so existing Prohibition consumers compile unchanged
* feat(1278): project check descriptor as flat scalars in projectProhibitions (wave 2)
- emit check_kind/check_target (+ check_rule only for lint-rule with a rule) when descriptor well-formed
- under-specified/descriptor-less items project byte-identically (CHK-07); flat scalars ride existing parseMustHavesBlock continuation-KV path (no parser rewrite)
- add CHK-02 probe-core unit cases pinning the projection
- turns CHK-03 parity test GREEN; dispositionForProhibition untouched
* feat(1278): descriptorFromProjection read-back adapter feeds fail-closed locate (wave 3)
- Add descriptorFromProjection(projected) -> CheckDescriptor | null to
src/prohibition-enforcement.cts: renames the projected flat scalars
check_kind/check_target/check_rule -> {kind,target,rule?}, or null when
the descriptor is absent/non-object (no check_kind key).
- failFirst is NEVER sourced from the projection (stays caller-attested; #1279).
- rule is set only when check_rule is a non-empty string; the adapter does NOT
re-validate kind/target/rule — an under-specified descriptor reconstructs to
one the EXISTING runProhibitionEnforcement LOCATE guard rejects (located:false,
never green). The merged #1259 guard stays the single source of fail-closed truth.
- Turns the RED CHK-06 fail-closed tests (plan 01-01) GREEN end-to-end; CHK-03 /
CHK-07 stay green. CheckDescriptor type, locate guard, dispositionForProhibition,
and parseMustHavesBlock are unchanged (additive +36/-0).
* feat(1278): verify-phase locates prohibition check from projected descriptor (wave 3)
- request.check kind/target/rule sourced from projected check_kind/check_target/check_rule via descriptorFromProjection, not verifier invention (CHK-05)
- replaces the #1278 author-supplied / tracked-follow-up note with the delivered deterministic-locate behavior
- preserves fail-closed routing: absent/partial descriptor -> never green, hard-gate in both modes
- failFirst stays a verify-time caller attestation; #1279 bounds the remaining fail-first proof
* feat(1278): spec-phase captures wired-check descriptor on test-tier resolution (wave 3)
- Step 5.6 'Keep it' / verification: test path captures check_kind/check_target/check_rule, projected onto must_haves.prohibitions for verify-phase deterministic locate (CHK-04)
- SOFT capture: a test-tier prohibition without a descriptor is still allowed (no hard authoring block); stays fail-closed/flagged downstream
- --auto captures only an unambiguous descriptor, never fabricates a check path
- failFirst NOT captured at spec-phase (verify-time attestation; #1279)
- PROB-06 soft-gate + text-mode (PROB-09) behavior unchanged
* chore(1278): re-baseline workflow size for grown verify-phase + spec-phase prose (wave 3)
- spec-phase.md 28438 -> 30343 (+1905), verify-phase.md 35362 -> 36498 (+1136)
- regenerated via npm run size:baseline (no hand-picked numbers); growth is the #1278 deterministic-locate + descriptor-capture prose
- workflow-size-budget guard green (122/122)
* docs(1278): ratify optional check descriptor in dated ADR-550 addendum + type:Changed changeset
- Append dated 2026-06-15 ADR-550 addendum ratifying the D3 prohibition-item
shape extension (optional flat-scalar check_kind/check_target/check_rule)
- Document flat-scalar rationale, deterministic projection/read-back,
fail-closed on partial/invalid/absent, #1279/policy out-of-scope
- Add .changeset/1278-prohibition-check-descriptor.md (type: Changed)
* docs(1278): document optional check descriptor in prohibition-probe reference + FEATURES
- Add 'Optional wired-check descriptor (deterministic locate, #1278)' section
to the prohibition-probe reference (flat-scalar keys, projection/read-back,
fail-closed + backward-compat, failFirst stays attested)
- Add deterministic prohibition-check descriptor source entry to FEATURES.md
- No CONTEXT.md glossary change: descriptor reuses existing wired-check /
verification:test vocabulary, no new glossary term introduced
* fix(1278): pass packaging gates — changeset pr field + retired slash-form fix
- Add required pr: 1278 to changeset (lint:changeset MISSING_PR hard requirement;
plan's 'omit if unknown' was inaccurate — issue number per #1259 convention,
updated to real PR number when opened) [Rule 3 - blocking]
- Fix retired /gsd-spec-phase -> /gsd:spec-phase at verify-phase.md:83 (wave-3
prose; caught by slash-namespace invariant #3443/bug-2543, blocked CHK-09
full-suite-green) [Rule 1 - bug]
- size:baseline + INVENTORY manifest verified in-sync post-build (no diff)
* docs(1278): add check descriptor + descriptorFromProjection to CONTEXT.md prohibition glossary
* fix(1278): harden descriptorFromProjection round-trip (numeric-coercion + stray-rule) per review
- MD-01/LW-01: narrow projected scalars to primitives + String()-coerce, so a
numeric-looking check_target (parseMustHavesBlock coerces ^\d+$ to number)
reconstructs as a string and locates instead of silently un-locating; no
as-string type-lie, satisfies no-base-to-string.
- LW-02: attach rule only for the lint-rule kind (drop a stray node-test rule).
- LW-03: document the optional check_* keys in the reference Output schema.
RED->GREEN tests added in prohibition-enforcement.test.cjs.
* chore(1278): set changeset pr to 1301
* test(1278): add fast-check property for the check-descriptor round-trip + fail-closed (trek-e review)
RULESET.TESTS.property-based-testing: the projectProhibitions -> render ->
parseMustHavesBlock -> descriptorFromProjection chain is a bijective/transformation
contract. Adds 2 fc properties to tests/probe-core.property.test.cjs (no new file;
ratchet stays at 2 for probe-core):
- well-formed descriptors survive the round-trip across the full string domain
incl. the numeric-coercion case (target/rule reconstruct as strings);
- under-specified/invalid descriptors (absent / target-less / rule-less /
unknown-kind) are always fail-closed (never green, flagged, unlocated).
Stability is asserted at the descriptorFromProjection layer (the raw parse step is
intentionally lossy for numeric scalars; the shared parser is unchanged).
---------
Co-authored-by: Tom Boucher <trekkie@nomorestars.com>
- rename tests/_ff_lint_violation.test.cjs -> .cjs so node --test does not execute the lint fixture (ENOENT on intentional lib/foo.cjs); scope local plugin to it so eslint . stays green (violation -> suppressedMessages, prover still proves it)
- migrate prohibition-probe.verify-tier.test.cjs A/B to inject proveFailFirst (FF-08: attestation alone no longer greens post-#1279)
- re-baseline verify-phase.md workflow size (35362 -> 35812) after the descriptor-shape prose grew
- changeset pr: TODO -> 1279 (issue number; update to PR number at open) so changeset + docs-required gates pass
- Add 5 FULL-producer e2e tests to the REAL-runner describe block, exercising
runProhibitionEnforcement with NO injected runCheck/proveFailFirst (the
SHIPPING defaultProveFailFirst + defaultRunCheck spawn real subprocesses).
- lint-rule: greens on the committed no-source-grep violation fixture + clean
target via real eslint; hard-gates on a toothless fixture in both modes.
- node-test: greens via the GSD_PROHIB_SUBJECT convention (red on bad fixture,
clean pass on clean subject); hard-gates without a fixture (FF-05).
- Closes the #1259 BL-01/SF-01 injected-double gap for fail-first (FF-10 capstone).
RED-first fail-closed guards on the prove seam, committed BEFORE the producer
change. All inject (or omit) proveFailFirst, which the current producer ignores
— so each FAILS against the attestation-greens code (actual 'green' vs
notStrictEqual 'green'). RED is INTENTIONAL; Plans 02-03 wire the default prover
and no-throw wrap to turn them green.
New tests:
- FF-05 no-fixture: node-test with no violationFixture, default prover (none
injected) -> fail-closed, never attestation fallback (RED now)
- FF-05 no-throw: a proveFailFirst that THROWS fails closed, never greens (RED)
- FF-04 both-modes: un-provable check hard-gates in interactive AND autonomous,
mode echoed (RED)
No source edited. 5 total #1279 guards now RED, 2 positive controls green.
Pre-existing 5 attestation-green tests untouched and still pass.
RED-first adversarial guards pinning machine-proven fail-first BEFORE any
producer change. They inject a new proveFailFirst option the current producer
does not read, so they FAIL against the attestation-greens code
(src/prohibition-enforcement.cts:411). This RED is INTENTIONAL — Plans 02-03
wire the prover and turn them green.
New tests:
- FF-01: attestation + clean pass but no machine proof -> hard-gate (currently
RED: producer greens on attestation; actual 'green' vs notStrictEqual 'green')
- FF-01 positive: proven-fail-first + clean pass -> green (passes now, pins shape)
- FF-04: passes-on-violation (prover could not prove red) -> hard-gate (RED)
- FF-04: fails-on-clean even when proven -> hard-gate (passes via runCheck:false)
No source edited. 2 new guards RED, 2 positive controls green.
Maintainer CHANGES_REQUESTED (reviewed e08667e5, pre-portability-fix):
- B1: lint-rule no longer greens an unparseable target (eslintHasFatalError -> fail
closed on any fatal/parse error) or an inline-suppressed violation (eslintJsonHasRule
now scans suppressedMessages too). RED-first + real-runner repros.
- B2: both child spawns get a bounded timeout (30s node / 60s eslint) + 16MiB maxBuffer;
timeout fails closed. Injectable timeoutMs (positive-only — 0/negative can't disable
the bound) enables a fast 1.5s hang test.
- M1: scoped verify-phase.md — the check descriptor is author-supplied for now; filed
#1278 for deterministic auto-locate of the descriptor (the locate half).
- M2: added tests/prohibition-enforcement.property.test.cjs (fast-check fail-closed
invariants; within the <=2-file budget).
- m1: tapTestNames excludes # SKIP/# TODO; parseNodeTestSummary tracks # cancelled;
isNonVacuousNodeTestPass requires cancelled===0.
- m2: scoped the determinism claim to the decision/parse layer (real runner is env-dependent).
- m3: filed #1279 for machine-proven fail-first (violation-fixture probe).
- n1: -- before target in both arg builders (option-injection). n2: dropped dead token.
- B3 (Windows npx) was already fixed in 2af76306 (pushed ~65s after the review).
Verified node 22 + 24; size baseline regenerated for the verify-phase note.
A mutant dropping baseOf() from the TARGET side of the node-test vacuity compare
survived — add the mirror case (relative TAP name vs absolute descriptor target,
both basename-normalized -> vacuous).
CI failed on node 24 + Windows in the real-runner E2E tests — real portability
bugs in the shipping runner, not test flakiness:
- node 24 names a zero-test file's TAP entry by ABSOLUTE path (node 22 used the
basename), so the exact-string vacuity discriminator misfired -> empty file
falsely greened. Now compares BASENAMES (separator-agnostic) -> robust across
OS + node version. Verified: empty file is non-green under node 24 locally.
- the lint-rule runner spawned 'npx', which execFileSync can't launch on Windows
(and failed fast on ubuntu-24). Now resolves the project's eslint CLI via
eslint/package.json and runs 'node <cli>' through process.execPath (portable;
no shell -> no injection). eslint absent -> fail-closed.
- node-test also spawns via process.execPath, not bare 'node'.
Also folds in round-3 WR-01: the probe-core inline comments still said
enforcement was 'deferred to a follow-up PR' — corrected (landed in #1259).
Strengthened the isNonVacuousNodeTestPass unit test to pin the basename clause
(absolute-path target). Verified 71/71 green under BOTH node 22 and node 24.
Round-2 adversarial review found the lint-rule runner falsely greened an
eslint-IGNORED target: eslint returns a length-1 "File ignored" result (ruleId
null) that passed the >=1-file vacuity guard while nothing was linted — reopening
the vacuous-green class. Fix: buildLintArgs now passes --no-warn-ignored so an
ignored path returns [] -> fails closed (verified + E2E test on an ignored
bin/lib artifact).
Also: wrap runCheck() so even a (test-injected) throwing runner fails closed
(NEW-WR-01, full no-throw contract); document the benign basename-naming
constraint on wired node-test names (NEW-WR-02, fail-closed).
Adversarial pre-submission review found the injected-runCheck tests masked a
non-functional real runner. Fixes:
- BL-01 (false green on vacuous test): the node-test runner now parses the TAP
summary and requires a NON-VACUOUS pass (>=1 test, >=1 pass, 0 fail) AND a
reported test named distinctly from the file — node --test counts an empty file
as one passing test, so counts alone could not catch it.
- SF-01 (lint anchor never greened): the lint-rule runner now runs the project
eslint as --format json and filters by ruleId, so plugin rules (local/*) load
via the flat config — bare --rule cannot load a plugin. local/no-source-grep
now genuinely greens (covered by a real, non-injected test).
- BL-02 (tautological fail-first): the runner no longer echoes the caller's
failFirst as if confirmed. failFirst is documented as caller-ATTESTED; the
producer requires attestation + a genuine non-vacuous pass. Machine-proven
fail-first (needs a violation fixture) is flagged as a tracked follow-up in
ADR-550, the changeset, FEATURES, the reference doc, and verify-phase.
- SF-02: added real-runner end-to-end tests (no injected runCheck) + pure,
exported parse/filter helpers (parseNodeTestSummary, tapTestNames,
eslintJsonHasRule, eslintFileResultCount) so the shipping branches are
mutation-pinned.
- NIT-01/02: LOCATE guard rejects empty-string rule and unknown kinds.
- Hardening: spawn checks with NODE_TEST_CONTEXT/NODE_OPTIONS scrubbed so an
ambient test-runner context cannot corrupt a verify-time result.
- Docs reconciled to the shipped behavior (no 'confirms fail-first' overclaim).
